As the state Basic Education Funding Commission wrestles with creating a new state formula for K-12 education, comments at the panel’s final hearing pointed to the difficulty of devising a formula that considers the varying needs of school districts.

The commission established by the Legislature is expected to recommend a formula by June 10. Monday’s session at the student union at the University of Pittsburgh was its 15th hearing. The panel also is getting financial data from about 100 school districts to consider as it draws up the proposal for the Legislature’s consideration.

Most of the speakers focused on Pittsburgh schools, including Mayor Bill Peduto; school superintendent Linda Lane; school solicitor Ira Weiss/ school chief operating officer Ronald Joseph; Carey Harris, executive director of A+ Schools, and Harold Grant of the Pittsburgh Federation of Teachers.

Pittsburgh speakers addressed the high costs in a district where 76.6 percent of the district’s students are economically disadvantaged, according to the state Department of Education.

Advertise with us

Mr. Weiss urged the panel to consider the permanence of “cost drivers” such as charter school, special education, transportation, English language learner instruction and pension costs. “To ignore that is to put children and families in peril,” he said.

The hearing also had a speaker from the suburbs, Amy Billerbeck, a board member in the Upper St. Clair School District, where 7.14 percent of the students are considered economically disadvantaged by the state. She said her district is “probably perceived as a district that shouldn’t be complaining,” but she said that since 2010 it has had to reduce staff and raise property taxes.

She asked for a predictable formula that allows districts to retain local control and use the money to meet their individual needs.

Another speaker came from a rural district, Hillary LeFay, a parent in Clarion Area School District, who fears that her district with about 800 students may face too many financial challenges to survive.

During the hearing, co-chair state Sen. Pat Browne, R-Allentown, referred to Pittsburgh’s high per pupil cost. He said it was significantly higher than other urban districts such as Philadelphia, Allentown and Lancaster, and higher than most in the state.

Advertise with us

According to the most recent state figures, Pittsburgh’s per pupil costs fell from $21,711 to 2010-11 to $20,594 in 2012-13. That took it from the eighth highest to the 29th highest.

Mr. Browne said that a formula based on a set amount as foundation funding for an adequate education would work against Pittsburgh, which he said already spends more than that would be.

Instead, he said a formula that provides what each district already gets and then distributes any new money by the new formula has the potential to provide additional money to Pittsburgh. He considers the needs of the state’s second largest district “compelling.”

Gov. Tom Wolf has proposed increasing basic education spending by $400 million, but it is uncertain what the Legislature ultimately will approve.

Education writer Eleanor Chute: echute@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1955.