Multiple versions of the same question were posed to the Penn Hills School District school board Monday night: How could the board be unaware of the dire state of the district's finances?
It was standing room only in the board room in Linton Middle School as board directors spent most of the public voting meeting defending themselves, and, in some cases, arguing with audience members and residents, in response to growing skepticism about the district's debt. The board contends that misleading information about the district's budget culminated in the need for the district to borrow up to $18 million to cover its everyday expenses.
Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Michael Della Vecchia approved a petition from the district last week allowing the district to borrow the money to cover an anticipated $10 million shortfall for the upcoming school year, in addition to an already existing $8.9 million deficit.
Board director Donald Kuhn made a motion toward the start of the meeting for the board to consider placing district business manager Richard Liberto on unpaid leave. Mr. Liberto was placed on paid leave after the district's bond rating was lowered because of its precarious finances.
"I believe [our finances] are the result of, to say the least, poor management and a lack of accountability," Mr. Kuhn said. "I see no reason for the district to acquire any additional charges as a result of the mismanagement of district funds."
Board president Denise Graham-Shealey immediately called for an executive session, where board members went behind closed doors to discuss the matter. When the meeting readjourned, district solicitor Craig Alexander said the administration would decide whether any employees needed to be considered for removal from the district. Acting superintendent Nancy Hines also said in an opening statement that the board recently discovered months of back pay owed to the district from a busing company leasing district property.
Read More
"It has become increasingly hard to sit and watch what has happened, what is happening and what is being said and be quiet and be professional and respectful," board vice president Jennifer Burgess-Johnson said during the meeting. "When we know better we do better, and what we are desperately trying to do is better."
However, during the public comment section, residents and former board members questioned how the board did not see the writing on the wall, including examples of former meeting minutes, discussions and expense reports. A review of independent audits of the district has shown a widening gap between revenues and expenses beginning in 2011-12, when the district withdrew $958,692 from a $4.65 million fund balance. The district then took $3.56 million from the fund balance in 2012-13, leaving $126,555.
The board Monday night voted down approval of its monthly school finance report in a 4-3 vote, and announced a special public voting session scheduled for 7 p.m. May 4 specifically to discuss district finances.
"You're wondering where all the money went. Well, it was mismanaged," former board member Erin Vecchio told board members to cheers and applause during public comment. "You're spending money we don't have. It doesn't take a college degree to be on this board. It takes common sense, and someone on this board needs to get some common sense."
Clarece Polke: cpolke@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1889 or Twitter: @clarepolke.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.