One state Senate aide, when the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette pointed out the language, surmised it was “an oversight.”
The bill’s prime sponsor went further Thursday, saying he now intends to propose an amendment as soon as possible correcting it.
State Senate legislation intended to require more public disclosure by Pennsylvania’s four state-related universities, as currently written, would enable them to shield from the public many of their largest employee salaries — figures they currently release.
Senate Bill 412, introduced this month by state Sen. John Blake, D-Lackawanna, is part of an effort to revamp Pennsylvania’s Right-to-Know Law that has been working its way through the Legislature for two years.
Mr. Blake said his bill’s intent is to give greater insight into the University of Pittsburgh, Penn State University, and Temple and Lincoln universities, which receive hundreds of millions of taxpayer dollars each year but largely are exempt from Right-to-Know requirements.
Indeed, his bill would create free accessible online databases with extensive budgetary information, non-personal employee and enrollment data, and would compel the four universities to list vendor contracts above $5,000 and maintain a 20-year archive of minutes from school trustee meetings.
Read More
But in one key area of disclosure — individual salaries — the bill’s language is at least a partial retreat.
Under the current Right-to-Know Law, last updated in 2008, the four universities must provide yearly any information required by the federal tax form 990, plus a list of their 25 largest employee salaries.
Under the legislation, Lincoln’s salary reporting requirement would not change, but Pitt, Penn State and Temple’s would. Those schools would list the highest-paid 200 employees, but faculty salaries would not be reported by specific amount, but rather in ranges.
The impact could be significant based on a look at what those schools reported under Right-to-Know last year.
At Penn State, it appears 14 of the 25 employees whose salaries exceeding $500,000 were disclosed could have been reported in ranges had Senate Bill 412 been in force. That’s because they hold faculty appointments and are not officers, directors, key employees or others whose compensation triggers federal reporting rules.
At Pitt, it appears 17 of the 25 highest-salaried employees earning $336,116 and up also could have been reported in ranges.
Mr. Blake acknowledged that things have changed since 2012, when public anger over the Jerry Sandusky child sex abuse scandal at Penn State fueled legislative momentum to bring the state-related schools fully under Right-to-Know.
“My original legislation would have called these institutions out as state agencies,” he said. “I ended up having to retreat from that.”
Still, Mr. Blake and his staff insisted Thursday there was no intent to free state-related schools from reporting the 25 highest salaries to the dollar. “If and when the bill is considered, he [Mr. Blake] would be absolutely inclined to have the bill amended to bring clarity and restore any reporting requirement that may have been inadvertently affected,” said Kyle Mullins, his legislative director.
He said Mr. Blake will ask a member of the Senate Government Committee, which has yet to meet on the bill, to introduce the change.
The size of the ranges is not yet set for faculty not among the top 25 earners. Mr. Blake has said ranges balance transparency with university unease that giving specific sums hinders recruiting and retention of talent. He added, “I would be willing to consider an argument to the contrary.”
Open-government advocates say such fears ignore that public universities beyond Pennsylvania generally are required by state law to report their own salaries.
Hawaii’s public salaries are reported in ranges, but in general, public salaries nationwide including public university employees are reported to the dollar, said Adam Marshall, a legal fellow with the Washington, D.C.-based Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press.
He said the rationale is that at government-funded institutions, “taxpayers have a right to know how money is being spent.” He said gender disparity can be greatest at top income levels, and exact salaries more clearly show if men and women are being compensated equally.
Lisa Powers, a Penn State spokeswoman, said ranges “give us a minimal degree of opaqueness” to avoid poaching of “our best faculty talent” who bring research funding into Pennsylvania. She said Penn State competes with private and public campuses. Pitt had no comment.
Language mandating disclosure of the top 200 campus salaries surfaced in June — initially without faculty salary ranges — in predecessor legislation, Senate Bill 444, sponsored by then-Majority Leader Dominic Pileggi, R-Delaware, author of the current Right-to-Know Law. A news release that month called the bill a dramatic expansion of state-related reporting requirements and mentioned the 200-salary requirement.
But three months later, salary range language was inserted into the bill just before it passed the Senate in an amendment introduced by Mr. Pileggi. The wording was incorporated into the Blake bill. Erik Arneson, a Pileggi aide, said at minimum the bill should still require the top 25 salaries by amount. “My off-the-cuff reaction is it was an oversight that is easily remedied,” he said.
In the House, where state Rep. Scott Conklin, D-Centre, is seeking to bring the schools fully under Right-to-Know, aide Tor Michaels agreed there should be no retreat. “We need more openness, not less,” he said.
Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter: @BschacknerPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.