MORGANTOWN, W.Va. -- A judge yesterday granted former West Virginia University Provost Gerald Lang's request to stop the university's upcoming academic disciplinary hearing against him.

The decision throws into doubt whether the university will pursue misconduct proceedings against Dr. Lang and five other former and current WVU officials connected to last year's degree scandal involving the daughter of West Virginia Gov. Joe Manchin.

Dr. Lang was to face academic misconduct charges brought by the university's Office of Academic Integrity. The confidential hearing was scheduled to begin Monday.

Dr. Lang filed suit in Monongalia County Circuit Court in February to block the proceedings, contending several university attorneys involved in the process had conflicts of interest.

Advertise with us

In his complaint, Dr. Lang contended that WVU general counsel Mary Roberta Brandt and deputy general counsel Beverly Kerr had conflicts because they were "involved with the events and participated in meetings" surrounding the granting of an unearned degree to Mylan Inc. executive Heather Bresch.

Circuit Court Judge Susan B. Tucker yesterday agreed with Dr. Lang, saying his due process rights were violated and that the university could easily have prevented the conflicts.

"Since the university did not fix the problem, I think this order will fix it," Judge Tucker said.

She said that while the conflicts may not have been deliberate, they created "at least the appearance of impropriety," tainting the process.

The judge ruled that the university must cancel the hearing against Dr. Lang, but she said the school could start over and initiate new proceedings.

Advertise with us

It was unclear whether the university would do that.

The head of the integrity office, law professor Marjorie A. McDiarmid, said she wanted to review the judge's order before making a decision.

Judge Tucker outlined the terms of her decision in court but said she would file a formal order later.

An attorney for the university, Assistant Attorney General Sam Spatafore, declined to comment as did Dr. Lang's Morgantown attorney, J. Michael Benninger.

It also was unclear whether the university would hold the hearing against the other men as scheduled on Monday.

Advertise with us

"The judge clearly does not want the case against [Dr.] Lang to go forward," Ms. McDiarmid said. "I don't know what the order will say with respect to the other people."

The other men facing misconduct charges are former WVU chief of staff Craig Walker and business school professors R. Stephen Sears, Cyril Logar, Gerald Blakely and Paul Speaker, according to an academic integrity report obtained by the Post-Gazette.

The ruling came one year after an independent panel of academics concluded that WVU officials falsified Ms. Bresch's student records to make it appear that she finished an M.B.A. degree she did not earn. Ms. Bresch is the daughter of Mr. Manchin.

The panel's report triggered the resignations of Michael Garrison as WVU president, Dr. Lang as provost, and Dr. Sears as dean of the business school. Dr. Lang and Dr. Sears still work at the university.

Three attorneys from two law firms representing Dr. Sears and another attorney representing Dr. Logar were in court yesterday trying to join Dr. Lang's suit.

Judge Tucker ruled against them, however, saying they filed their motions too late.