Five current and former employees of West Virginia University besides ex-Provost Gerald Lang are facing charges of academic misconduct at the school for their role in granting an unearned M.B.A. degree to Mylan Inc. executive Heather Bresch, daughter of West Virginia Gov. Joe Manchin, according to an academic integrity report obtained by the Post-Gazette.

WVU's Office of Academic Integrity plans a disciplinary hearing April 27-May 1 against Dr. Lang, former chief of staff Craig Walker and business school professors R. Stephen Sears, Cyril Logar, Gerald Blakely and Paul Speaker, according to the report.

The report, which says "a preponderance of the evidence warrants a hearing" against the six men, was identified as an exhibit in a court filing yesterday by Dr. Lang, who in February sued to block the disciplinary hearing.

The report states that "fabrication and falsification of grades" falls within the definition of academic misconduct.

Advertise with us

WVU has declined comment, saying proceedings by the academic integrity office are confidential.

Last spring, an investigative panel found that administrators falsified Ms. Bresch's student records to make it appear she earned a master's degree in business administration, adding 22 credits to her transcript along with grades "pulled from thin air." The five-member panel of academics was formed after a Post-Gazette story raised questions about how the university went about retroactively granting the degree nearly 10 years after Ms. Bresch left the program.

Dr. Lang resigned as provost in the wake of the panel's report along with Dr. Sears, who had been dean of the business school. Both continue to work for the university. The scandal also forced the resignation of President Michael Garrison, who left the university last summer along with his chief of staff, Mr. Walker.

The report by the academic integrity office, completed in February, concluded that Mr. Walker and Drs. Lang, Blakely, Logar and Sears should face a hearing on whether they "collaborated in fabricating or falsifying the grades in question."

In addition, it said, evidence justifies a hearing on whether Dr. Speaker and Mr. Walker "contributed to the misconduct in question" by withholding information "which, had it been known, would have changed the decision to award the grades."

Advertise with us

Dr. Sears, through his Washington, D.C., attorney Thomas A. Clare, said yesterday he denied the allegations of academic misconduct and intended to vigorously defend himself.

Drs. Logar, Blakely and Speaker did not return e-mails seeking comment. Mr. Walker could not be reached.

Yesterday's filing by Dr. Lang was a response to a motion by WVU to dismiss his case. In it, Dr. Lang contends that the proceedings against him should be dropped because university attorneys involved in the process have conflicts of interest.

"There is nothing that can be done at this time except stop the proceeding," Dr. Lang's Morgantown attorney, J. Michael Benninger, said yesterday. Removing the attorneys in question from the case is not an option, he said, because "the damage has already been done."

WVU contends there are no conflicts of interest. A hearing on the university's motion to dismiss Dr. Lang's case is scheduled to be heard by Monongalia County Circuit Court Judge Susan B. Tucker tomorrow morning.

Advertise with us

The academic integrity report concluded that in October 2007 the business school directed the university's Office of Admissions and Records to award Ms. Bresch "a grade of 'B' for 16 credits in six courses," information previously reported by the Post-Gazette.

"It is uncontested that Ms. Bresch did not complete those courses," the report states.

The admissions office also was instructed to change grades in two other courses on Ms. Bresch's transcript from incomplete to "A," the report said, information also previously reported by the newspaper.

"It is uncontested that no effort was made to determine whether the work in those courses had, in fact, been completed or whether 'A' was the appropriate grade," the report said.

Dr. Lang's petition yesterday took issue with the fact that the university's integrity office did not issue misconduct charges against former chief counsel Alex Macia, who left the school last summer. Mr. Macia and former communications director Bill Case are the only people who attended pivotal meetings in which the decision was made to grant Ms. Bresch the degree who are not facing charges.

Advertise with us

The fact that Mr. Macia was left out is at the heart of Dr. Lang's argument alleging conflict of interest.

WVU Deputy General Counsel Beverly Kerr participated in proceedings that found "there was no evidence that the allegations against her boss had merit, thereby clearing him from further scrutiny and investigation," according to the filing.

"At the very same time," the filing said, Ms. Kerr "found that allegations of academic misconduct against Petitioner Lang and others had merit."