MORGANTOWN, W.Va. -- A final analysis of West Virginia University's record-keeping practices found the school awarded far fewer undocumented degrees than previously thought, according to a consultant's report released yesterday.

However, the American Association of Collegiate Registrars and Admissions Officers still said the university granted more than 100 degrees for which it no longer has supporting documentation.

The report emphasized that there was no "pattern of favoritism or malfeasance" in the awarding of those degrees.

The analysis, ordered last fall by interim university President C. Peter Magrath, was prompted by a degree scandal involving the West Virginia governor's daughter that led to the resignation of WVU President Michael Garrison last year.

Advertise with us

AACRAO said it was unable to find records verifying 104 undergraduate degrees and 14 executive M.B.A. degrees awarded at WVU from 1997 through 2008. In a February preliminary report, 271 undergraduate degrees and 27 M.B.A. degrees had been identified as having record discrepancies.

As with their initial report, the consultants said the problems were the result of substandard record-keeping practices.

WVU has made "significant progress" toward implementing all 29 recommendations AACRAO made in February for overhauling the university's records systems, interim Provost Jane Martin said yesterday.

Chief among those recommendations was establishing an Office of the University Registrar and making it the official custodian of all academic records. The search for a registrar is "well under way," Dr. Magrath said.

WVU hired the consultant after an investigative panel determined that top school officials falsified records to retroactively award an unearned executive M.B.A. degree to Mylan Inc. executive Heather Bresch, adding 22 credits to her transcript along with grades "pulled from thin air" to satisfy the requirements of the 48-credit hour program. Ms. Bresch is the daughter of West Virginia Gov. Joe Manchin.

Advertise with us

Before the transcript was altered, official school records showed Ms. Bresch did not receive a degree in December 1998 as she had claimed.

AACRAO's review involved students who were granted degrees despite record discrepancies. The consultant concluded that most of those degrees were legitimately awarded to graduates whose transcripts did not reflect the fact that they had completed the required number of credits. Those cases involved credits from other schools that were not transferred to WVU records, requirements that were waived by a provost or dean, computer glitches and other acceptable explanations, AACRAO reported.

During the period of time AACRAO reviewed, WVU awarded 36,661 undergraduate degrees and 652 M.B.A degrees.

For the 104 undergraduate and 14 M.B.A. degrees, the students appeared to be short of the credits required to graduate and no records exist to "prove or disprove" that the degrees were earned, the consultant said. But in every case, the degrees were certified by the college at the time of graduation and all students received their degrees, the report said.

Dr. Magrath reiterated yesterday that those degrees will stand.

Advertise with us

A week before he announced his resignation, Mr. Garrison told WVU's Board of Governors that there were problems with about 70 M.B.A. degrees awarded over the period AACRAO reviewed.

AACRAO Consulting Director Bob Bontrager said missing records are common at many universities but that the situation goes unreported. It came to light at WVU because the degree erroneously awarded to Ms. Bresch focused attention on the school's record-keeping system.

Dr. Magrath called the Bresch scandal "unfortunate and regrettable," but said it came with a "silver lining, even a gold lining."

"We will have a [record-keeping] system as good as we can possibly have on this planet," said Dr. Magrath, who will be succeeded as president June 30 by Towson University Provost James Clements.