SAT college entrance exam scores released yesterday show the largest point decline nationwide in three decades, but College Board officials said it's largely a byproduct of fewer students opting to retake the expanded exam.
Graphic: SAT scores
Still, how the high school Class of 2006 performed is revving up the debate over test changes rolled out in March 2005.
For the first time, the test included a third section with an essay hand-written in 25 minutes. The point total of 1600 was expanded to 2400 -- 800 each for math, critical reading (formerly called verbal) and writing.
The new SAT also included harder math problems, got rid of analogies and took a bigger bite out of test-takers' wallets at a cost of $41.50, up from $28.50.
The test takes 3 hours and 45 minutes to complete on average, an increase of 45 minutes that officials with the College Board, owners of the SAT, insisted did not affect how students fared.
The scores show these changes from last year:
Critical reading averaged 503, a drop of five point's from last year's verbal test and two points below that of a decade ago. Males, averaging 505, did better than females, averaging 502.
Math averaged 518, a drop of two points from last year although it remains 10 points higher than that of a decade ago. This year, males, averaging 536, did better than females, averaging 502.
The new writing component averaged 497, with females outscoring males, the first time females have done better than males on a section. Females averaged 502; males averaged 491. Those who wrote in cursive received higher scores while those who used first-person essays received lower scores.
Nationwide, the combined seven-point decline in the average score in critical reading and math was the largest point drop since 1975. Even so, College Board President Gaston Caperton was upbeat in assessing the revamped exam.
"We strongly believe that the addition of writing has made the SAT a better measure of the skills students need to succeed in college and in work," Mr. Caperton said. "We have created an improved test which we believe raises national standards."
Mr. Caperton attributed the decline to changes in student behaviors that typically accompany test modifications. He said the drop in math was equal to "about one-fifth of one question" and the decline in critical reading equaled only about half a question.
"Mathematically, it means almost nothing," he said.
Students who take the exam a second time typically improve their scores by 30 points, and in doing so positively influence the national average. This year, 44 percent of test-takers opted to re-take the exam, down from 47 percent.
"If they reduced the time to take it and the money it costs, kids would take it a second time," said Joanna Schultz, director of college counseling at The Ellis School.
The 1.46 million test-takers was about 9,800 fewer than last year.
College Board officials said that their study showed that students did just as well early in the lengthy test as they did at the end of the test.
But Drew Deutsch, vice president of the Princeton Review, which helps prepare students for the tests, is unconvinced.
He said extensive input from students and admissions counselors shows that "students really had a tough time concentrating on a test that is considerably lon ger than the old test."
Yesterday's results were foreshadowed in the spring as a number of colleges reported unexplained declines in SAT scores of their incoming freshmen. The College Board also has been dealing with criticisms of test scoring errors that affected some 5,000 students who took the test last fall.
"I think the days of the College Board as sort of this omnipotent, omniscient, all-powerful group, I think those days may be numbered," said Alton Newell, vice president of enrollment at Washington & Jefferson College. "I think people are asking questions."
Yesterday, the response from exam critics was swift.
The National Center for Fair & Open Testing, a Cambridge, Mass., group long critical of standardized testing, said the decline both in scores and in the number taking the SAT "add to the mounting credibility problems" facing the College Board.
"As recently as this spring, they assured test-takers and admissions offices that scores from their 'new' SAT would be consistent with the previous version," said Bob Schaeffer, FairTest public education director. "Now they have to explain how and why the revised exam led to lower scores."
He predicted more colleges would make the tests optional.
Brandon Jones, an official with Kaplan Test Prep & Admissions, said an area of concern was the decline of more than 17,000 test-takers from households making under $20,000. Score results by minority group were mixed, with some showing higher scores and others lower results.
Mr. Deutsch sees a "slow migration" to the ACT college entrance exam, an achievement test with an optional essay. Colleges often accept either SAT or ACT scores.
ACT recently reported its scores are up.
Test-takers tend to divide along geographic lines. In Pennsylvania, only 9 percent of the Class of 2006 took the ACT while 74 percent took the SAT. There were only 803 more ACT test-takers in Pennsylvania in this year's class than the previous one.
Many colleges have paid little attention to the writing portion of the SAT because they have no comparative data.
Michael Steidel, director of admissions at Carnegie Mellon University, said this year the university will look to see how performance on the writing portion relates to how freshmen do on campus.
At the University of Pittsburgh, vice provost Patty Beason said Pitt won't be considering the writing score in its admissions this year because it, too, is studying the patterns.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.