One of three men accused in a multi-county murder plot was sentenced Tuesday to life in prison, although not before he attempted to fire his second attorney in just over a month.

William Fortuna, 61, maintained his innocence as Common Pleas Judge Jill E. Rangos issued the mandatory sentence for first-degree murder: Life in prison without the possibility of parole.

Fortuna and two others — 43-year-old Jeremy Fisher and his nephew, 22-year-old Braden Elliott — were charged in late 2023 with the disappearance and murder of George Dayieb. Authorities say Dayieb, 57, was murdered Dec. 27, 2023, inside Fisher’s truck along Route 422 in Butler County.

Rangos called the shooting and attempted cover-up a senseless crime. So, too, did Dayieb’s longtime girlfriend.

Advertise with us

“This was just so stupid and senseless,” Kendra Remich told the judge. “I can’t ever wrap my head around why. Like, how? Why? He was everything to me.”

Authorities said Fisher and Fortuna orchestrated the plot to kill Dayieb over a business debt owed by Fisher, and they convinced Elliott to be their triggerman.

“Why?” Remich asked. “Over money? It doesn’t mean anything.”

A jury earlier this year convicted Fortuna of first-degree murder for his role in the deadly plot.

Though Fortuna was not in the vehicle with Fisher and Elliott when Elliott allegedly shot Dayieb in the back of the head, earlier testimony indicated he gave Elliott the revolver that was ultimately used to kill the Murrysville businessman.

Advertise with us

Fortuna fired his trial attorney, Stephen Colafella, shortly before he was originally set to be formally sentenced in August. Rangos appointed Brandon Michael Herring to represent Fortuna and postponed sentencing until Tuesday.

Before the hearing began, Herring told Rangos he had received word a day earlier that Fortuna no longer wanted his representation. He said his client was claiming ineffective assistance of counsel — an argument generally reserved for the appeals process.

“I can’t imagine how you could be ineffective between the time of the postponement and today,” Rangos mused.

Herring said Fortuna wanted him to file a motion for a mistrial — something that has to be done before a jury renders a verdict — as well as several post-sentencing motions. He said he tried to explain that “post” means “after.”

Fortuna told Rangos: “I don’t feel that the man did anything for me.”

Advertise with us

She asked Fortuna if he was asking to represent himself as, once he fired his court-appointed attorney, she was not permitted to appoint him new counsel.

“I’m not smart enough to do that,” he said.

He ultimately elected to allow Herring to represent him through sentencing and post-sentencing motions, telling the judge, “I’ll keep him for now.”

Herring acknowledged that Fortuna was facing a mandatory sentence on the murder conviction but asked Rangos not to sentence him to the maximum of 20 to 40 years for the conspiracy conviction. He said that prosecutors early in the case attempted to secure Fortuna’s cooperation in the case against Fisher, as they had with Elliott, but that “did not bear fruit.”

Elliott previously testified that his uncle first asked him to kill Dayieb — whom Fisher allegedly owed a great deal of money — the day before the murder. He balked at the request, he said at a preliminary hearing in early 2024, and continued to reject the idea when Fisher asked him multiple times throughout the day.

Advertise with us

Early Dec. 27, 2023, Fisher and Elliott met Fortuna for coffee, and his uncle again asked him to kill Dayieb, he testified at the time. He promised him a truck, and Elliott said yes. Fortuna gave him a revolver.

Fisher and Elliott picked up Dayieb a short time later: Fisher drove, Dayieb sat in the passenger seat, Elliott sat behind him, and Fortuna trailed behind the trio in his own truck. The revolver jammed the first time Elliott tried to open fire, and authorities said Fortuna fixed the issue when they pulled over at a gas station. His second attempt was successful, he testified at his preliminary hearing.

According to the testimony, Fortuna and Fisher told Elliott to take Dayieb’s body to “camp” — a pair of trailers on a plot of land in Clarion County. Elliott said he assumed the other two would follow.

Instead, Elliott was left to take care of Dayieb’s body himself. He said he texted his uncle and Fortuna for help. He told Fortuna he needed help with “the pipe” — code he had been instructed to use in reference to Dayieb’s body. Fortuna told him to take care of “the pipe” himself. He dragged Dayieb into the trailer and left him there. His truck got stuck, and Fortuna ultimately came and took him home. They went to retrieve the truck the next day.

The plan unraveled later on Dec. 27 when Dayieb’s truck was found abandoned near McKees Rocks. Allegheny County police Detective Stephen Hitchings said Dayieb’s girlfriend said he had gone to meet Fisher about a business debt Dayieb was owed.

Advertise with us

Police found Dayieb’s body in the trailer in Clarion County on Dec. 29.

Fisher and Elliott are both charged with homicide and conspiracy in connection with the killing. Beyond that, Fisher is also charged in a separate but related case with solicitation of homicide. He’s accused of offering another man $50,000 for “offing George.”

Fisher is scheduled for trial in May. Proceedings for Elliott are set for March.