It remained unclear Thursday afternoon whether the man accused of stabbing an Edgewood couple as they slept the night prior knew the couple or broke into the Linden Avenue home at random, authorities said.
Idris Evans, a physician at UPMC Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh, died shortly after the stabbing, which police said happened about 12:30 a.m. as he and his wife slept. His wife remained in critical but stable condition.
Elijah Hemingway, 32, of Pittsburgh’s Hazelwood neighborhood, is charged with homicide, attempted homicide, aggravated assault and burglary. He was taken into custody shortly after the police arrived at the home, tracked by a Monroeville K-9 unit to some bushes at a home next door.
“We do not know if there was any preexisting relationship,” Vic Joseph, assistant superintendent of Allegheny County police, said midafternoon Thursday, roughly 16 hours after the attack. “The female half [of the couple] did not know [Hemingway]. We’re trying to determine if the two males knew each other — it’s unclear right now.”
The couple’s two children were in the home at the time but were uninjured, police said.
A UPMC spokesperson confirmed that Evans was a medical director at UPMC Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh.
“Dr. Evans was a dedicated caregiver and valued member of our hospital and university communities,” a spokesperson said in a statement.
According to the criminal complaint filed against Hemingway, the surviving victim told investigators she awoke to find a man in his underwear — later identified as Hemingway — stabbing them. She said he was “psychotic” and made repeated references to “‘God’ and being ‘God,’” detectives wrote.
The woman said she didn’t know Hemingway but recalled her husband addressing Hemingway by his first name “as if he knew him,” according to the complaint.
Joseph said it’s unclear whether Evans actually knew Hemingway or if Hemingway had identified himself as Elijah during the attack.
Hemingway told detectives after his arrest that Evans had invited him to the home hours earlier, according to the complaint. He said he arrived on his bicycle and Evans let him inside.
“Hemingway then went on to allege that [Evans] attacked him with a ‘Michael Myers’ style knife” and a struggle ensued, investigators wrote. He alleged he was stabbed in the back during the fight but ultimately disarmed Evans and stabbed the couple.
Investigators noted that Hemingway “did not have a stab wound on his back” as they interviewed him, and he was unable to tell police where he met Evans or where he put his bike once he arrived in Edgewood, as investigators said they found no bicycle at the scene.
“He said he was an invited guest: There’s zero evidence to support that,” Joseph said.
The woman told investigators the couple attempted to fight back, and Joseph said the scene was one of disarray, with broken furniture and blood on the floor and walls.
“It was a very violent scene,” he said.
Authorities found a “large kitchen knife” in a third-story bathroom — the same floor where the couple’s bedroom was located. The backdoor to the home was open with blood on the handle, according to the complaint, and an adjacent kitchen window was open “with suspected blood at its base and a Leatherman-style multi-tool nearby.”
The woman said after the attack Hemingway demanded her car keys, which she turned over, and she ran to a neighbor’s home for help. Police said they found the keys near where Hemingway was ultimately taken into custody.
Hemingway’s criminal history in Pennsylvania is limited to Allegheny, and it’s made up almost entirely of traffic violations and summary citations for disorderly conduct.
He was charged in February with burglary and theft after he allegedly went into an ex-girlfriend’s North Side home while she was gone and took several electronics. A preliminary hearing on those charges was scheduled for next week.
Hemingway remained hospitalized for injuries to his hands Thursday afternoon. A preliminary hearing in the homicide case will be scheduled after he is released and arraigned.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.