Over and over again, Carly Shelleby asked why.

She asked why her former husband would hurt his own family this way, and she asked him why it was so easy for him to send their Castle Shannon home up in flames.

She asked why she wasn’t able to save her daughter, 19-year-old Lakyn, and why she couldn’t have died in her place.

“Why?” she asked.

Advertise with us

“She is everywhere. She is in my heart, she is in my mind,” Carly Shelleby said ahead of her ex-husband’s sentencing for third-degree murder. “I miss my daughter. I miss my best friend.”

“Tell me why,” she said.

Brian Shelleby sat a few feet behind her, flanked by his defense attorneys in Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Bruce Beemer’s courtroom Thursday. Clad in the standard-issue fluorescent green Allegheny County Jail jumpsuit with his hands shackled to his waist, Brian Shelleby sat with his shoulders slumped.

He had pleaded guilty one month earlier to causing the fire that killed his daughter. In exchange for his plea to third-degree murder and aggravated arson, prosecutors agreed to a sentence of 15 to 30 years in prison.

The last time Carly Shelleby saw her daughter was the night before the fire. She had gotten off early from her shift at Sheetz, and she woke her mom up by pulling on her toes. She told her about her shift, and Carly Shelleby said she told her daughter to get some sleep.

Advertise with us

“The last words we said to each other were, ‘I love you,’ ” she said, telling the judge she had no way of knowing that it would be the last “I love you” she ever heard from Lakyn. She had no way of knowing, she continued, that “he would take her away from me.”

“Our beautiful daughter — he killed his own daughter,” she said.

She wept throughout her victim impact statement, although her voice became steadier the longer she spoke. She spoke of Lakyn’s love of animals and how talented she was on the saxophone. She was a sophomore at the University of Pittsburgh. She was just 19, and sassy, passionate and determined.

And she spoke of her marriage, conceding that for the past few years she and Brian Shelleby “struggled to be happy.” She said she had tried to fix it — to help him — but it ended in empty accusations of infidelity.

“How was it so easy for him to burn us alive?” she asked.

Advertise with us

Beemer, an imposing figure who has served at length in law and the judiciary, at times looked pained as Carly Shelleby spoke. More than once, he lowered his head into his hand.

Brian Shelleby wrote in a statement read by his attorney, Phil DiLucente, that he wakes up each day and it’s that Sunday morning again.

“I wish every day I could have saved her life or that it was me who perished,” he wrote.

He said he wanted to take responsibility for his actions, and he pleaded guilty last month to spare his family a homicide trial.

“I have to live with what I did every day,” he wrote. “That day, part of me died with her. I wish every day I could take that day back — every single day.”

Advertise with us

The fire, just under a year ago on Sept. 14, destroyed the Shelleby’s Castle Shannon home. Lakyn died in the flames — investigators found her, unresponsive and severely burned, about 20 feet from the front door. Carly Shelleby suffered severe burns over half of her body, and she spent weeks hospitalized.

In the minutes prior to the explosion and blaze, Brian Shelleby had poured gasoline in the home’s basement, up the stairs, and throughout the main floor. He and his then-wife were separating, and they fought that morning.

Carly Shelleby told Beemer that she had a normal morning: Coffee on the couch with the dogs and then into the kitchen to start breakfast. She said when she saw her husband that morning, his eyes were black and empty.

“I met the devil that day,” she said.

When the gasoline fumes ignited — the fire marshal couldn’t say for certain whether they were lit intentionally or sparked by the gas stove — Carly Shelleby “was up in flames.” She described the graphic visual of her burning legs and melting socks, and her efforts to get to the second floor to help Lakyn.

Advertise with us

“I realized she wasn’t coming out, and I couldn’t get in,” she said, then spoke to her ex-husband: “How could you do this to us, your family?”

Her son — Brian Shelleby’s stepson — said the terror in his mother’s voice when she called him that morning is “not something I’ll ever forget.”

Nathan Butler said that while his mother was hospitalized, it fell to him to identify his sister’s body. All that remained of her, he said, were her tattoos. He said the medical examiner’s office explained to him that an open casket would not be an option.

“I pray he finds his way to heaven,” Butler said of Brian Shelleby. “I pray Lakyn has one more sassy argument with him before he gets kicked out.”

Brian Shelleby’s father, Michael Shelleby, described the shocked-turned-grief that followed the fatal fire.

Advertise with us

“Why?” he said. “Why did this have to happen?”

Beemer, ahead of formally sentencing Brian Shelleby, said he has seen a lot over the years in his courtroom. Even so, he said, “it’s hard to comprehend the depth of this tragedy.”

He said Lakyn should be heading into her 20s “with the world at her back, figuring out what she can do to change it.”

“The greatest tragedy here is that Lakyn isn’t here anymore,” Beemer said. “There really is nothing else for the court to say.”