Jurors deliberated for less than four hours Thursday before finding a 21-year-old Wilkinsburg man guilty of third-degree murder in the 2022 shooting of 18-year-old Maleek Thomas.
Shaun Scott was acquitted of first-degree murder in the Hill District shooting, meaning jurors did not believe the shootout that afternoon was a premeditated attack.
But their verdict also means they did not believe defense attorney Frank C. Walker II’s argument that his client opened fire because he was in fear for his life — that he expected Thomas and another man to ambush him.
Thomas’ mother, Camille Baskins, attended every day of the trial in the Allegheny County Common Pleas courtroom, just as she did for Scott’s first homicide trial, involving a different victim, in October. In that case, Scott was convicted of first-degree murder in the March 2022 death of 15-year-old Dayvon Vickers.
As the jury foreman read off “not guilty” after “first-degree murder,” Baskins’ eyes flew open wide. She wept as he said they found Scott guilty of third-degree murder.
She called the trial and verdict “a long time coming.”
Read More
The trial began Monday afternoon, and it relied heavily on surveillance video collected from the scene as well as identifiable pieces of clothing investigators linked back to Scott — pieces of clothing that Scott had tried to get rid of, according to Assistant District Attorney Matthew Rabinowitz.
“Those actions are not typical of someone who fired in self-defense,” he said, noting that Scott fired at least 14 shots. That, he said, showed premeditation.
“He intended to kill Maleek Thomas,” Rabinowitz said.
Questioned by police days after the June 24, 2022, shooting, Scott admitted to the shooting but said it was in self-defense. He told police, according to Rabinowitz, that a “fat dude in a red shirt” started shooting at him, and then Thomas started shooting as well.
No man in a red shirt was ever seen in the surveillance footage, he said, and the video showed Thomas pulled his own gun only after Scott started shooting. Rabinowitz told jurors that a picture speaks a thousand words but, in this case, it’s pictures and videos.
“[Scott] admitted being the shooter,” he said. “Other than that, nothing he said is really true.”
Walker argued that the prosecution didn’t prove that Scott specifically intended to kill Thomas.
Jurors, amid deliberations, asked to rewatch some of the video presented at trial. Walker said he believed that indicated his argument made sense to them.
Scott faces a maximum sentence of 40 years in prison in Thomas’ murder. He was sentenced to 35 years to life in prison in Dayvon’s murder. The mandatory sentence for adults convicted of first-degree murder in Pennsylvania is life without the possibility of parole; Scott was 17 when he shot Dayvon in Homewood.
Sentencing in the Thomas case has not been scheduled.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.