Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. said Tuesday he’s issued “a list of demands” to ownership of a troubled South Side bar — demands, the DA said, that must be agreed to within 48 hours or else he will seek to have the establishment shut down.

Capo’s, in the 1400 block of East Carson Street, came under Zappala’s microscope earlier this month after he said a woman escorted out by security was later raped in a nearby parking lot.

“She’s visibly intoxicated, and she’s led out of that establishment by security,” the DA said in an update on the bar’s status Thursday. “They don’t take care of her. She winds up in the hands of a rapist.”

A representative of Capo’s could not immediately be reached.

Advertise with us

Zappala called the incident “the last straw” in a series of issues at the bar, which is in the heart of the South Side’s entertainment district. He pointed to reports of fights and assaults in and around the establishment dating back to last year.

He said at the time he was prepared to file the petition the very next day. On Friday, though, his office said the DA was holding off on filing anything until a sit-down between ownership and his Nuisance Bar Task Force on Tuesday.

That meeting, according to the statement released around 4:30 p.m., ended with the list of demands and 48-hour deadline. The statement did not list the demands made of the bar, saying only that the demands are “necessary to improve and protect the safety of patrons.”

Several South Side organizations, however, said in an open letter to city officials that the bar — which bills itself on social media as “the best rooftop bar and college vibes on Carson” — does not deserve any more chances.

Signed by the South Side Community Council, South Side Community Action Network and the South Side Chamber of Commerce, the letter expressed dismay that Capo’s “may once again be offered remediation as an alternative to meaningful action against its liquor license.”

Advertise with us

“Remediation can be an appropriate response when an otherwise responsible operator experiences an isolated problem and demonstrates both the willingness and the ability to correct it,” the organizations wrote. “It is far less appropriate when an establishment has developed a lengthy record of incidents, police involvement, neighborhood complaints, and adverse impacts on the surrounding community.”

The letter pointed to the Aug. 9 sexual assault in a parking lot along South 14th Street.

Larry Pappy Johnson, 37, faces a litany of charges in connection with the alleged attack, which police say was caught entirely on security cameras: rape, sexual assault, robbery, false imprisonment, indecent assault, indecent exposure and harassment.

The charges against Johnson were filed last week, and he was taken into custody by Pittsburgh’s Fugitive Apprehension and Special Victims units days later in Staten Island, N.Y.

Police allege Johnson dragged an intoxicated woman into a 14th Street parking lot and raped her before taking her cellphone, purse and Apple Watch. The criminal complaint against Johnson notes that the woman was limp and unable to hold herself up as she was dragged into a corner of the parking lot.

Advertise with us

The South Side organizations wrote that while the criminal case against Johnson has yet to play out, the incident “cannot be viewed in isolation from” Capo’s broader record.

“At some point,” according to the letter, “remediation stops being a remedy and becomes another postponement of accountability.”

The letter further alleged a “troubling … repeated reluctance” of government and other officials to take action against problem bars.

“Residents are routinely told that another meeting will be held, another agreement will be negotiated, another set of operating conditions will be imposed, or another opportunity for remediation will be provided.”

“Meanwhile,” the letter continued, “the neighborhood continues to pay the price.”

Advertise with us

Zappala, in his statement Tuesday, maintained that if Capo’s does not agree to his terms, “our office is prepared to file a petition for the closure of the establishment.”

If Capo’s does agree to the terms, he said, he will ask the mayor for his blessing and “our agreement will be embodied in a court order, which may require the filing of the petition.”