Philip Everton McPherson crashed two planes, almost crashed a third and was banned from flying with passengers.
But he gave flight lessons anyway.
His plane crashed in September 2022 in a residential backyard in Salisbury Township, killing 49-year-old student pilot Keith Kozel, an Easton resident and a father of two.
McPherson, 37, of Haddon Township, N.J., was sentenced to 6½ years in prison Thursday for manslaughter and related charges.
“The toll McPherson’s actions have taken on [Kozel’s] family is irreparable,” U.S. Attorney David Metcalf wrote in a sentencing memorandum, also signed by two assistant U.S. attorneys.
The owner of the flight school, Palmer Township resident Nouman Saleem, was sentenced to 2½ years in prison for fraud and related charges. He admitted he ignored McPherson’s flight ban and let him keep teaching.
McPherson failed his pilot certification examination twice, finally passing the third time in December 2019, court records say. His first crash came four months later, according to the U.S. attorney’s sentencing memo. He crashed again, then nearly crashed when he was flying with a Federal Aviation Administration official who was assessing whether he deserved to keep his certification. The FAA official had to take control of the plane, then banned McPherson from flying.
McPherson flew anyway. He logged more than 40 flight lessons without proper certification, collecting more than $100,000 in ill-gotten payments on behalf of Bethlehem Township-based Proflight Aero flight school.
McPherson pleaded guilty to 43 of the 44 charges against him, then withdrew the plea and claimed the crash with Kozel was due to engine failure, not pilot error.
“Whether for crashing planes at his first flight school, failing his re-examination, or causing the death of a student pilot, McPherson’s reactions have been similar – defiance, opposition, and indignation,” prosecutors wrote in the sentencing memorandum.
McPherson’s attorney disagreed with the federal probation office’s interpretation of the sentencing guidelines. Defense attorney Joseph D. Mancano said the sentencing range should have been set at 46 to 57 months, not the 70- to 87-month range considered by the judge. Prosecutors asked for a sentence above the guidelines; Mancano argued for a sentence below the guidelines.
McPherson was genuinely remorseful, according to his sister. She said he broke both of his legs during the crash and had to be dragged from the plane wreckage but begged to be let free so he could try to rescue Kozel.
“To me, this reflects the true measure of his character,” McPherson’s sister, Ayana McPherson, wrote in a letter to U.S. District Judge John Gallagher.
In another letter to the judge, McPherson’s friend, Dominick Bolella, said McPherson will never get over Kozel’s death.
“He has told me that one of the heaviest burdens on his heart is wondering whether Keith’s family hates him, or whether they see him as the reason Keith is gone,” Bolella wrote.
If he really cared about the welfare of others, he wouldn’t have flown, the prosecution wrote in the memo. McPherson was stubborn and refused to accept the growing evidence that he’s not a safe pilot, the memo says.
He didn’t make it back to Queen City Airport in Allentown but was lucky he didn’t crash into Lehigh Valley Hospital, less than a mile from the crash site, or into Salisbury Middle School, which he flew over seconds before he crashed, prosecutors said.
The prosecutors asked for a stiff prison sentence because they’re afraid McPherson will try to fly again. McPherson took a job as a dispatcher at an airport after the Kozel crash, they wrote.
“There is zero evidence that McPherson even acknowledges the significant danger to himself and others posed by his actions, which is most concerning due to his potential ability to seek employment and certification in the aviation field in the future,” they wrote.
Saleem cooperated with authorities and disbanded the flight school, according to a memo filed by his attorney, John Waldron of Allentown. Prosecutors asked for “imprisonment” but didn’t indicate whether Saleem should be sentenced in the guideline range of 41 to 51 months.
“To his credit, Saleem admitted his faults, and unlike McPherson, has not attempted to excuse his behavior,” prosecutors wrote.
McPherson pleaded guilty in October to involuntary manslaughter, obstruction of an administrative proceeding, conspiracy to commit wire fraud, criminal conspiracy and serving as an airman without a certificate. Judge Gallagher refused to allow him to withdraw his plea.
Saleem admitted last year he allowed McPherson to keep teaching student pilots even though he was unlicensed and a safety risk. Saleem pleaded guilty to obstruction of an administrative proceeding, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and criminal conspiracy.
McPherson was ordered to pay back $19,530 to the people who took flight lessons from him when he was uncertified. Saleem was ordered to pay back $81,998.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.