A jury on Friday convicted a McKeesport man of first-degree murder and first-degree murder of an unborn child in the 2021 shooting that killed Karli Short and the child she was carrying.
Isaac Smith will face a mandatory sentence of life in prison without the possibility of parole. Sentencing is set for Tuesday morning, a deviation from the standard 90 days allowed by state law.
Attorneys said jurors deliberated for about 90 minutes.
The District Attorney’s Office initially sought the death penalty against Smith, but prosecutors dropped their bid for capital punishment last year, citing only the “due consideration of all of the relevant facts and circumstances.”
Short, 26, was shot and killed shortly after midnight Sept. 13, 2021, just yards from the home where she was staying with her cousin and uncle.
A neighbor discovered her body around 10:30 a.m. on the sidewalk leading from the backdoor of the home to the rear alley.
Read More
She was about five months pregnant, and she believed Smith was the father, according to trial testimony.
DNA results that came back earlier this month ultimately revealed that Smith was not the father of the child, something his defense attorney, Tom N. Farrell, in his opening statement alleged Smith already knew.
He said his client had no reason to kill Short: He’d already told her that he would be a father to the child — if it was his. But he didn’t believe that would be the case after a DNA test, Farrell said, as he’d worn a condom when he was with Short.
Farrell said that his client “liked women,” and he’d been involved with many in McKeesport. He told jurors “not to lose [their] common sense at the door.”
Deputy District Attorney Ryan Kiray said in his opening remarks to the jury that Short was “ready to trumpet [Smith’s] name as the father of that unborn child.” He said Smith was leading a double life — including having a serious girlfriend that he’d introduced to his family the day before Short’s murder.
Short was planning a gender reveal party, Kiray said, and alleged Smith’s double life was about to fall apart.
Among the evidence presented over the course of the seven days of testimony were the recordings for Smith’s two interviews with Allegheny County police.
“He was respectful and cooperative,” Detective Mark Restori said of Smith’s first interview the evening after Short was killed. He said he “whole-heartedly” believed Smith when he said he had nothing to do with the murder.
“We totally believed he was telling the truth,” he said.
Smith was arrested about two months later. In that interview, detectives berated Smith.
“You know what I find despicable,” Detective Kevin McCue said on the recording from inside the interrogation room. “You go out and you kill Karli and your unborn child and you’re still out there trying to [pick up women].”
Over and over, he shouted at Smith:
“You killed your [expletive] kid and you killed Karli — you did it. You killed Karli and your unborn [expletive] child.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.