Testimony began Tuesday in the trial of a man accused of luring his pregnant paramour from her McKeesport home and shooting her in the head, all in a bid to keep his “double life” from crumbling around him, prosecutors alleged.
The case against Isaac Smith, said Deputy District Attorney Ryan Kiray, is about “the consequences of living a double life and ultimately about the tragedy that follows after one takes measures to conceal it.”
Smith, 30, is charged with homicide and homicide of an unborn child in the 2021 killing of Karli Short and the child she was pregnant with.
The District Attorney’s Office initially sought the death penalty against Smith but dropped that bid last year. Prosecutors are asking the jury to convict Smith of two counts of first-degree murder.
Short, 26, was shot and killed shortly after midnight Sept. 13, 2021, just yards from the home where she was staying with her cousin and uncle. A neighbor discovered her body around 10:30 a.m. on the sidewalk leading from the backdoor of the home to the rear alley.
She was about five months pregnant, and she believed Smith was the father.
Read More
“Karli Short was ready to trumpet his name as the father of that unborn child,” Kiray said.
But Smith had a serious girlfriend — one he had introduced to his family just a day prior, authorities said. Despite the way he presented himself, he was “carrying on affairs behind the back of his long-term girlfriend and family,” Kiray said.
Smith, the prosecutor said, felt the walls closing in on him.
He told jurors that Smith’s burner phone was the one that called Short minutes before she walked out her backdoor, and a revolver he had bought six weeks before the homicide — and pawned two weeks after — was determined to have fired the fatal shot.
“The circumstantial evidence — the phone, motive, gun, all the rest — will lead you to the defendant the same as if someone was standing right next to him,” he said.
It would turn out that Smith was not the child’s father — a revelation that came only recently with the results of the paternity test.
Kiray said that doesn’t matter: At the time, Short believed Smith was the father, and she told him as much. She was planning a gender reveal party. She asked him for his guest list.
Defense attorney Thomas N. Farrell told jurors his client, who was adopted, “cherished unborn children” and had no reason to kill Short: He’d already told her that he would be a father to the child — if it was his. But he didn’t believe that would be the case after a DNA test, Farrell said, as he’d worn a condom when he was with Short.
He said that his client “liked women.”
“He liked women, and he fooled around with women, and he liked a lot of women,” he said, and alluded to the fact that some of those women would know where Smith’s spare key was and how to get into his house.
“They all talked,” Farrell said. “Don’t lose your common sense at the door.”
His client is innocent, Farrell told jurors.
“You have to listen to the evidence,” he said. “You have to evaluate the evidence.”
He said that while Smith had someone buy the burner phone for him, it was eventually transferred into his name. He pawned the revolver, “which he didn’t throw in the river.” Why would he do that, Farrell asked, if Short’s murder was some “elaborate plan?”
Testimony will continue Wednesday morning.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.