The Pennsylvania State Supreme Court on Thursday ruled that blanket mandatory life sentences for convictions of second-degree murder are unconstitutional.

The landmark case was argued in front of the state’s highest court more than a year ago. Second-degree murder, also called felony murder, applies when someone is killed during the commission of a separate felony — for example, if someone is killed during a robbery.

Reform advocates have long pointed to the fact that even if someone who participated in the crime did not actually kill anyone, that person can still be charged and convicted of second-degree murder.

The case was brought by Derek Lee, who was convicted in Allegheny County in 2014 for his participation in a robbery that ended in a fatal shooting. His case will be sent back to Common Pleas Court to be resentenced.

Advertise with us

Chief Justice Debra Todd wrote in her opinion that the blanket mandatory sentence, which leaves no room for questions of actual culpability, “is inconsistent with the protections bestowed upon our citizens under the ‘cruel punishments’ clause of our Commonwealth’s organic charter.”

Justice Todd noted that the decision addresses only the blanket nature of the felony murder sentence — that is, she said, it is the mandatory part of the sentence that is the unconstitutional part.

“Rather,” she wrote, “we hold that offenders convicted of second-degree murder must receive a meaningful consideration of release, based upon their individual culpability and the circumstances surrounding their crime.”

Lee, now 38, broke into a home in Pittsburgh's Elliott neighborhood in October 2014 with an accomplice, Paul Durham. The pair shepherded the man and woman inside into the basement where Lee pistol-whipped and used a Taser on them. Lee's attorneys have said his intent was to steal, not kill, and that Durham shot and killed the man in a scuffle while Lee was upstairs. Both men were convicted of second-degree murder and given the mandatory sentence.

The court’s opinion — nearly unanimous save for Justice Kevin Brobson’s opinion that partially concurred and partially dissented — did not address whether changes could or should be retroactive.

Advertise with us

The court stayed its ruling for 120 days in order to give the Legislature time to amend the statutes surrounding the now-unconstitutional sentencing structure.

Quinn Cozzens, an Abolitionist Law Center attorney who worked on Lee’s case, said that could come in the form of updating the state’s parole code to set a mandatory minimum sentence for those convicted of felony murder. Among the other options would be resentencing hearings for Pennsylvania inmates serving life sentences for second-degree murder.

Mr. Cozzens said the legislature could address the decision retroactivity but that it otherwise might be determined through future litigation.

It’s the way the country’s ban on sentencing juveniles to life without the possibility of parole played out in the 2010s: The U.S. Supreme Court case Miller v. Alabama ruled it unconstitutional for those who were children at the time of their crimes to be sentenced to life without parole. A second case four years later, Montgomery v. Louisiana, made it retroactive.

Those federal rulings resulted in some 500 incarcerated individuals being resentenced in Pennsylvania.

Advertise with us

Gov. Josh Shapiro filed a friend-of-the-court brief supporting Lee in 2024. In it, he wrote that the Department of Corrections estimated there were, at the time, about 1,042 inmates serving such sentences across the state.

According to the filing, about half of those defendants were the actual killer culpable in the crime. In the other half of the cases, there was an even split between those in which the defendant was clearly not the actual killer and those in which it wasn’t clear.

“Notwithstanding the differences, a conviction for second-degree murder results in the same mandatory minimum sentence as those convicted of first-degree murder — life in prison without the possibility of parole,” Mr. Shapiro wrote. “This is simply wrong.”

On Thursday, the governor applauded the Supreme Court’s decision.

“I have long believed this law is unjust and wrong,” he said, pointing to the brief he’d submitted in support of Lee’s case. “Common sense and true justice dictate that we need different penalties for different conduct.

Advertise with us

“For example,” he continued, “the getaway driver shouldn’t get the same sentence as the person who pulled the trigger.”

He called on the state Legislature to move forward on a “thoughtful, just process” to address those already serving life sentences for second-degree murder.

The Abolitionist Law Center’s Brett Grote argued Lee’s case in front of state Supreme Court judges in Pittsburgh in October 2024.

“This ruling represents the culmination of decades of movement-building by incarcerated people and their families and communities, while also marking the onset of a new phase in the struggle to abolish death by incarceration,” Mr. Grote said in a statement.

Mr. Cozzens called the ruling a “massive step forward in recognizing that sentences must be appropriately tailored to the individual.”

Advertise with us

Celeste Trusty, a former secretary of the state Board of Pardons under the Wolf administration who is now a director with Families Against Mandatory Minimums, called the mandatory sentence “antiquated and draconian.”

“Judges should have the flexibility to consider the facts and circumstances of each unique case,” she said in a statement, pointing to the hope that it will give “to families and people who have been behind bars for longer than necessary.”

Lee himself released a statement Thursday through the Abolitionist Law Center.

“I humbly thank all my brothers and sisters behind the walls of every institution in the state for your support, words of encouragement, and, most of all, for your prayers,” he wrote. “I commend the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania and acknowledge the countless individuals and organizations who have put a hand to the plow in a conglomerative effort to push this case to victory.”