A Homewood woman pleaded guilty Tuesday to voluntary manslaughter in connection with the fatal stabbing of another woman that was the culmination of an hourslong argument between the two.
Court records show 22-year-old Maurissa Plummer pleaded guilty in exchange for four to 10 years in prison. She faced one count of homicide in the Oct. 15, 2024, death of 27-year-old Raneisha Scott.
Police responded to the 6800 block of Lyric Street shortly before 5 a.m. the day of the stabbing after an anonymous 911 caller reported that “one of the girls is chasing the other one with a knife,” according to the criminal complaint.
A witness reported hearing an argument outside shortly before the stabbing and, upon looking outside, saw Plummer chasing Ms. Scott with a knife, police wrote. A few minutes later, the witness heard Ms. Scott say “you stabbed me,” to which Plummer allegedly replied, “I did.”
Investigators said security footage from Plummer’s apartment — about 250 feet from Ms. Scott’s home — showed the defendant before and after the stabbing. According to the complaint, the footage captured Plummer saying she “just used a pocket knife.”
Police said at the time that numerous members of Ms. Scott’s family arrived at the scene in the aftermath of the stabbing, telling investigators that Plummer was still in the nearby apartment and posting to social media.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.