The father of a family whose Plum residence was destroyed by a gas explosion and fire at 5021 Hialeah Drive in April 2022 has been charged with attempted criminal homicide and arson.

Jacob Rabb allegedly disconnected the pipe that delivered natural gas to the clothes dryer in his basement, causing large quantities of the fuel to flood the basement and, finding an ignition source, explode after 11 p.m. on April 22, as Mr. Rabb, his then girlfriend and two of the couple’s children slept, according to a criminal complaint.

Their third child, an 11-year-old- boy, was in the basement playing video games, the complaint said. He managed to escape the fire through a window and sustained first-degree burns. The rest of the family fled the house as it crumbled around them, engulfed in flames, according to the document.

Mr. Rabb was arrested on Monday and is being held without bail. As the investigation in this case wandered through utility records, metal analysis and a review of oil and gas infrastructure in the area, Mr. Rabb allegedly confessed several times to different people that he blew up the house, intending to kill everyone inside, the criminal complaint states.

Advertise with us

While his then partner, Laura Petty, initially credited Mr. Rabb for saving the family by organizing a quick exit after the explosion, the couple’s relationship unraveled soon afterward, the document says. A few days before Christmas in 2022, she told him she wanted to end it; a week later, Mr. Rabb left an MP3 player in the home’s mailbox with farewell videos to his family, and disappeared. Ms. Petty reported him missing, according to the document, “after he made suicidal statements.”

In May 2023, two days after Ms. Petty filed for a restraining order against her former partner, the complaint says she found a note in a kitchen cabinet that said: “If I can’t have her no one will or my kids see you all in hell” followed by a crude phrase. Another note said: “P.S. I did Blow up the House,” the complaint states.

In June, Mr. Rabb came into Ms. Petty’s house in the early morning hours, held a knife to her throat and threatened to kill her, the document states. He then cut his own arm and said “he intended to provoke police to shoot him.” He had also confessed to Ms. Petty that he “disconnected the gas valve,” she told detectives.

Mr. Rabb was sentenced to three to six months in jail for the assault. He denied confessing to Ms. Petty, but, according to the complaint, his father also told detectives that Mr. Rabb confessed to him, saying “I started it,” in reference to the fire, and, “Dad I blew up the house.”

In November 2025, the complaint states, the supervisor of a three-quarter house — also called a sober house where those recovering from drug addiction can live under some supervision — told detectives that Mr. Rabb, who was staying there, said he “intended to kill himself, his ex-girlfriend, and his children, and then have his last meal at Buffalo Wild Wings.”

Advertise with us

Three attempts

Mr. Rabb and Ms. Petty had lived in the Plum home for less than three months before the explosion. Mr. Rabb had installed the natural gas appliances in it, he told investigators.

The couple’s oldest son told investigators that the “entire basement smelled like natural gas” when he went down there to play video games that night, the document states. Neighbors interviewed after the explosion also said they smelled “a strong unusual odor that caused them to return inside” on the evening of April 22.

A record of 911 calls in Plum that day shows no calls about a gas smell.

Records from Peoples Natural Gas, the utility that serves the area, showed that a large amount of gas flowed through the meter at the couple’s house for seven hours preceding the explosion. Experts calculated that it was at least 65% more gas than would be required if all natural gas appliances were working at their maximum capacity at the same time, the complaint explains.

The night of the explosion was the third time this happened, the document states. The gas company registered extremely high flows on two other days leading up to the fire: two three-hour stretches on April 18, and one two-hour period of unusual gas consumption on April 21.

Advertise with us

“This data supports that a gas valve/line has been manually manipulated allowing for the free flow of gas,” Plum police Det. Daniel Moriarty wrote in the criminal complaint.

Plum has seen its share of gas-related explosions and near misses in recent years. A fatal house explosion in Rustic Ridge that killed six people in August 2023 is still being investigated by the Allegheny County Fire Marshal.

In December, a Plum man was charged with creating a gas leak in his home and leaving two candles burning, with the intent to cause an explosion, according to KDKA.

Newer gas utility meters may be able to diagnose such problems before they reach dangerous saturations inside a home. Peoples, for example, began in 2024 to install Itron gas meters that are programmed to shut off automatically if they register very high flows of gas or very high temperatures.