Christina Potter cast a hard look at the man at the defense table as she made her way to the front of Common Pleas Judge Bruce Beemer’s fifth-floor courtroom Tuesday.

“This is the biggest tragedy I’ve ever had in my life,” Ms. Potter told the judge. “I don’t wish this on anyone.”

Behind her, 23-year-old Marquis St. Julien-Givner sat with shoulders slouched, facing a mandatory life sentence in the 2023 murders of Ms. Potter’s daughter and granddaughter: 21-year-old Temani Lewis and 4-year-old Kaari Thompson.

St. Julien-Givner was convicted of murder following a bench trial in late November. He was tried alongside co-defendant Tarrell Jennings, who opted for a jury trial. The cases were tried together: While a deadlocked jury caused a mistrial in Mr. Jennings’ case, Judge Beemer convicted St. Julien-Givner of two counts of first-degree murder.

Advertise with us

Assistant District Attorney Diana Page asked the judge to run the two life sentences consecutively “based on the egregious, calculated and vicious nature of this defendant’s actions.”

She said that Ms. Potter told her after St. Julien-Givner’s conviction “she felt that after all this time she could finally sleep.”

Judge Beemer agreed: He said that running the two life sentences concurrently, or simultaneously, would “undercut the fact two individuals lost their lives.”

“The devastation is incalculable,” he said, noting that Kaari would be in elementary school at this point.

“That child I don’t think could be more innocent in this,” he said.

Advertise with us

Ms. Lewis, her boyfriend, and Kaari stopped at the Brooklyn Food Mart near the intersection of Lincoln and Lemington avenues around 6:30 p.m. Dec. 1, 2022. Ms. Lewis went into the store while the toddler and Ms. Lewis’ boyfriend waited in her green Jeep.

Ms. Lewis returned minutes later. She had just opened her car door when four shooters surrounded the vehicle and opened fire. Kaari died later that night, and her mother a week later. Pittsburgh police filed homicide charges the following October against St. Julien-Givner and Mr. Jennings.

No one else has been charged in connection with the shooting.

Mr. Jennings’ retrial is scheduled for June 9.

“It’s hard to explain the level of calculation and viciousness that goes along with multiple individuals encircling a vehicle and indiscriminately opening fire,” Judge Beemer said.

Advertise with us

St. Julien-Givner maintained his innocence, and his attorney indicated his client intends to appeal his conviction.

“I do feel bad for the people going through this tragic moment right now but … that’s not the type of person I am,” St. Julien-Givner said.