A fractured family’s grief bubbled over in an Allegheny County courtroom Wednesday as friends and family members of Miranda Grimm-Gilarski confronted her killer ahead of his mandatory sentencing to life in prison.
“There are moments I still expect her to come through the door or message me again,” Danielle Gilarski told Common Pleas Judge Thomas Flaherty before the victim’s sister dissolved into sobs.
Her hands shook violently as she smoothed her handwritten statement on the witness stand in front of her.
“Nothing will bring Miranda back, but accountability matters,” she said, shooting a look toward the defense table at Darion Abel, the man convicted of murdering her sister in November 2018.
A jury in September convicted Abel of first-degree murder. Abel, now 27, shot his 19-year-old girlfriend 17 times the night of Nov. 17, 2018, and then drove himself to the Munhall police station to turn himself in.
Through sobs, Danielle Gilarski said her daughter was just a year old when Ms. Grimm-Gilarski was killed. At 8 years old, she said, “she looks just like her. … She acts just like her.” She said she has only partial custody of her daughter because of the incredible toll that her sister’s murder has had on her mental health.
Read More
Ms. Grimm-Gilarski’s father, Dennis Grimm, held up photos of his daughter on the witness stand.
“This is all we got left,” he said.
One photo was of him and his daughter on Christmas, he noted, then told the judge: “This is the home where she was shot 17 times.”
All family members, regardless of which side of the family they were on, described Ms. Grimm-Gilarski as an energetic and loving young woman. Her stepmother, Angelique Grimm, said she had grown close to her stepdaughter in the two years she had been in her life.
“I wish I’d had longer,” she said, telling the judge she had “never felt pain” like the pain she felt the day Ms. Grimm-Gilarski was killed.
“I felt my heart literally break,” she said.
Abel delivered a tearful statement to Ms. Grimm-Gilarski’s family before he was formally sentenced. He called the woman he killed the love of his life.
“Daily, I ask myself, ‘What were you thinking? Why would you do that?’ It all boils down to one selfish act,” he said, that caused a “ripple effect of hurricane-like pain and sorrow.”
Speaking directly to Ms. Grimm-Gilarski’s family, he said he prays daily for them to “grant me the mercy I am not worthy of.”
His defense attorney, Patrick Thomassey, said he understood that Judge Flaherty’s hands were tied: A first-degree murder conviction in Pennsylvania carries a mandatory life sentence without the possibility of parole. He argued during the trial that his client was not in his right mind when he killed Ms. Grimm-Gilarski, pushing for a conviction of guilty but mentally ill.
He reiterated that belief to Judge Flaherty on Wednesday.
“I have never seen anything this — this not understandable,” he said.
Abel had no criminal history prior to the night in 2018 when he shot his girlfriend more than a dozen times. Those moments, Mr. Thomassey said, were aberrations amid an otherwise responsible and caring life.
One of Ms. Grimm-Gilarski’s loved ones left the courtroom angrily, muttering as he did that “that dude was perfectly fine.”
Judge Flaherty echoed Mr. Thomassey’s belief that the killing was an aberration.
“Nevertheless,” he said, “that does not take away the lifetime of pain the Grimm-Gilarskis have.”
He told Abel he hopes he will receive psychological treatment in prison.
“You’ll have to deal daily with the unspeakable act that you did.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.