The defense attorney for a man already granted a new trial argued Tuesday a Deputy District Attorney mismanaged the case so badly it constituted prosecutorial misconduct — so severe, he said, that his client shouldn’t even be retried for a 2022 murder of a coworker in Scott Township.

“Yes, we got [a retrial], but this is so much bigger — it’s become so much bigger,” said Ryan Harrison James, a defense attorney who works on ethics- and civil rights-related cases.

Zairye Simmons, 27, had already been granted a new trial months earlier based upon the way Deputy District Attorney Jarrod Caruso mishandled evidence in the case — essentially by failing to present any evidence to support ancillary charges against Simmons: carrying a firearm without a license and receiving stolen property.

But taking those charges all the way through trial without evidence to present to jurors, Mr. James said, was reckless and amounted to prosecutorial misconduct. Because of that, he argued, double jeopardy should come into play: He asked Common Pleas Judge Bruce Beemer to bar a retrial altogether.

Advertise with us

“This is unprecedented, and unprecedented actions of this magnitude require unprecedented relief,” Mr. James told the judge.

A jury in January convicted Simmons of first-degree murder in the shooting death of Dorian Carver, who was an employee at Taco Bell on Cochran Road where Simmons was a manager. A fight preceded the shooting, and Simmons followed Mr. Carver out of the restaurant, into the lobby of another nearby business, and opened fire.

Judge Beemer ultimately acquitted Simmons of the two lesser charges before jurors began deliberations. Jurors, however, had already been told they’d be hearing a case in which the defendant was accused of using a stolen gun.

Though Judge Beemer offered instruction to jurors — that they should disregard what they’d heard about those two charges — Mr. James said that wasn’t enough. Judge Beemer granted his motion for a new trial in August after the District Attorney’s office conceded that Mr. Caruso mishandled the case by failing to withdraw the charges for which he had no evidence.

Mr. James argued Tuesday that that isn’t enough — that Mr. Caruso acted recklessly and without regard for his client’s rights, and prosecutors should be barred from retrying the murder case. He conceded that he and his client got what they wanted when they were granted a new trial, “but it’s bigger than that.”

Advertise with us

Specifically, Mr. Caruso waited until the trial had already begun to query the state as to whether Simmons had a license to carry a firearm and, despite having access to contact information for the man from whom the gun was stolen, he made no effort to subpoena him as a witness.

Deputy District Attorney Ronald Wabby Jr., though, argued for the DA’s office that Mr. Caruso’s actions were neither intentional nor reckless.

“There is no conscious disregard in this case — at best, its negligence,” he said, telling the judge what it came down to was that “Mr. Caruso was an ineffective prosecutor that day.

“That doesn’t mean he was reckless,” he said. “It just means he made a mistake.”

Mr. James questioned Mr. Caruso on the witness stand for more than half an hour about what evidence he knew he did and didn’t have and when he knew it.

Advertise with us

He presented a series of emails and text messages between Mr. Caruso and Allegheny County Police Detective William Hermann, the lead investigator in the case. He pointed to emails in which Det. Hermann laid out witness and evidence lists months before the trial began, asking Mr. Caruso if at any point he realized he didn’t have a witness to back up the stolen gun allegations.

Mr. Caruso, who’d been with the DA’s office for nearly 25 years at that point, had not tried a jury case in nearly a decade. He’d never tried a homicide case.

In one text message to Det. Hermann, Mr. Caruso referred to having “dropped the ball” in regard to certain documents related to the firearm. Mr. Caruso said he meant he dropped the ball in getting them to Simmons’ trial defense attorney in a timely manner.

In another text message, he told the detective the case “just has me over-stressed.” In yet another just days before jury selection in the case, he said he should have been more organized.

“I never feel fully prepared anytime I do a trial,” Mr. Caruso said on the stand. “I always feel there’s more I can do.”

Advertise with us

During brief questioning from Mr. Wabby, Mr. Caruso said his primary focus was on the homicide charge. Asked by Mr. James why he didn’t just drop the gun and stolen property charges, he said he “wasn’t thinking about that.”

“You’re obligated to think about it,” Mr. James said. “You have the ethical obligation to make sure you have evidence you can marshal into court.”

Judge Beemer noted Mr. Caruso made the effort to verify whether or not Simmons had a license to carry — it just came too late.

“What’s more important now, societally, is that Mr. Simmons shouldn’t be put through [another trial] when his government … did what they did here,” Mr. James said, calling it “inexcusable” Mr. Caruso went through an entire homicide trial “with two effectively meaningless charges without any evidence.”

Mr. Wabby reiterated the fact there was no conscious disregard for Simmons’ rights; rather, he said, it was a mistake.

Advertise with us

“Some could say a rookie mistake,” he added, noting: “They got what they asked for. They asked for a retrial and got it.”

Judge Beemer gave Mr. James 30 days to put his arguments into writing, after which Mr. Wabby will have 30 days to respond. Simmons is currently set to be retried on the homicide charged early next year