A judge on Monday convicted a man of first-degree murder in the 2022 deaths of a young woman and her toddler daughter.
Common Pleas Judge Bruce Beemer said the timeline of events on Dec. 1, 2022, and circumstantial evidence left him no reasonable doubt as to Marquise St. Julien-Givner’s role in the shooting: It was clear, he said, the 23-year-old was among the four people who encircled and opened fire on Temani Lewis’ green Jeep outside a Lincoln-Lemington market that evening.
Ms. Lewis and her 4-year-old daughter, Kaari Thompson, were killed in the shooting.
St. Julien-Givner’s co-defendant, Tarrell Jennings, opted for a jury trial, although the two were still tried together. Jurors, however, considered only the evidence against Mr. Jennings, while Judge Beemer rendered his verdict solely for St. Julien-Givner.
Jurors in the case against Mr. Jennings told the judge on Thursday they were “hopelessly deadlocked” after only a few hours of deliberations. Judge Beemer declared a mistrial. A new trial date has not been set.
St. Julien-Givner faces a mandatory sentence of life without parole for the first-degree murder convictions. Sentencing is scheduled for Feb. 17.
Read More
Judge Beemer said the circumstantial evidence in the case against St. Julien-Givner “was overwhelming” and left “no reasonable doubt … as to his culpability in this matter.”
Video evidence presented in the case showed the movements of the group that investigators said included St. Julien-Givner and Mr. Jennings in the hours leading up to the shooting outside the Brooklyn Market.
He was clearly in the footage taken from a Chipotle in the hours before the shooting as he, Mr. Jennings, and two others picked up a car from Mr. Jennings mother, the judge said, and St. Julien-Givner had identified himself as one of the individuals seen in footage from a gas station not far from the shooting scene.
The judge noted the defendant’s distinct pants, which he said were “readily apparent” in footage from another security camera at a different market minutes before the shooting. While video from the shooting scene didn’t clearly show St. Julien-Givner, it wasn’t reasonable to believe he had left the group in the short timeframe between the last time he was seen on camera and the shooting.
In addition to two counts of first-degree murder, the judge found St. Julien-Givner guilty of conspiracy and attempted homicide. He remained expressionless as he was led from the courtroom.
Detectives in the case hugged Assistant District Attorney Diana Page.
In her opening statement, Ms. Page described the scene outside the convenience store: Ms. Lewis had just picked up her boyfriend from a friend’s house, and the trio — Ms. Lewis, her boyfriend, and Kaari — stopped at the Brooklyn Food Mart on the way home. Ms. Lewis, a regular at the store, Ms. Page said, went inside while her boyfriend and daughter waited in Ms. Lewis’ green Jeep.
“Not even seconds after closing the driver’s door,” Ms. Page said, “there is a rain of gunshots on green Jeep.”
Kaari died the night of the shooting. Her mother died a week later.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.