No one in the courtroom Wednesday morning disputed that Connor Makstutis shot and killed Richard Derkach in rush-hour traffic on Banksville Road in March 2023.

Assistant District Attorney Matthew Newman laid out the chain of events: Mr. Derkach pulled his maroon Kia minivan behind Mr. Makstutis’ silver Ford Ranger near the intersection with Crane Avenue shortly before 5 p.m.

Mr. Derkach got out of his vehicle and went to the driver’s side window of Mr. Makstutis’ Ford. After a brief interaction between the two men, Mr. Makstutis shot Mr. Derkach three times in the chest.

Mr. Derkach got back in his Kia and drifted a few dozen yards before coming to a stop.

Advertise with us

Mr. Makstutis drove away and later turned himself in at Pittsburgh police headquarters.

Indeed, defense attorney Lee Rothman agreed — that is what happened.

“My client shot somebody,” he said. “My client shot somebody and drove directly to Pittsburgh police and said, ‘I shot somebody.’ ”

But why it happened and whether Mr. Rothman’s client was justified in doing so is the question that will ultimately be posed to the jury.

Mr. Rothman said the men knew each other — both lived in Brookline where, the defense attorney said, everyone knows everyone. And in this instance, he told jurors in his opening statement, people knew that Mr. Makstutis had been “harassed, badgered and threatened” by Mr. Derkach.

Advertise with us

Investigators, Mr. Rothman said, “didn’t try to find out why this happened.” He claimed that jurors will hear about threats he claimed Mr. Derkach made toward his client and his family, and he indicated that Mr. Derkach had previously shot at the defendant.

Jurors will see, Mr. Rothman said, that his client feared for his life when Mr. Derkach got out of his minivan and walked up to his window in traffic — that he was justified in opening fire.

But Mr. Newman said the simple fact that Mr. Derkach was clearly unarmed — a fact he said is shown on surveillance cameras that captured the shooting — means none of it was justified.

“You’ll see in the video that he has nothing in his hands,” he said.

Testimony in the case will continue Thursday morning.