Family members of Davon Smith wept as the footage played out on the large screen in Pittsburgh Municipal Court late Friday morning.
The first angle showed Randell Tate shooting at Mr. Smith and another man inside the Lawrenceville gas station where he was a clerk, which sent the two fleeing out onto Butler Street.
The second angle showed Mr. Smith fall to the pavement, wounded, as Mr. Tate continued to shoot at him from the threshold of the Sunoco’s front door.
“Overkill,” one of Mr. Smith’s loved ones gasped.
George Lawrence Saba, Mr. Tate’s defense attorney, said his client simply “exercised his constitutional right to defend himself in his place of work.”
Mr. Tate’s family members filled one side of the First Avenue courtroom while Mr. Smith’s filled the other, though the groups intermingled as Mr. Smith’s loved ones huddled and craned their necks to try to see the scene unfold on screen.
Sheriff’s deputies in Mr. Tate’s preliminary hearing had to warn multiple people more than once to stay quiet, to the point that District Judge Ronald A. Arnoni shouted from the bench for silence.
The Aug. 2 shooting began as some sort of confrontation inside the gas station. Mr. Tate told Detective Joseph Fabus that he was working the overnight shift and was inside the bulletproof cashier booth when Mr. Smith and another man came in around 3:30 a.m.
He said he and the other man exchanged a few words about a past issue, and Detective Fabus testified Mr. Tate told him the man “used harsh language but [he] wasn’t concerned about him.” He said Mr. Smith didn’t speak to him, and he did not see either man with a gun.
The footage from inside the store showed Mr. Tate standing in the doorway to the secure cashier booth before Mr. Smith and the other man follow him into the vestibule. The detective said Mr. Tate told him he grabbed his gun, turned and started shooting. He told the detective he did not pause before he opened fire.
The footage showed Mr. Tate follow the men as they fled out the front door, where he continued to shoot from the doorway. Mr. Smith fell to the ground as Mr. Tate continued to fire before he eventually made it into a vehicle. The other man, police said, flagged down a passing motorcyclist who took him to nearby Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh, which is where Mr. Smith ended up, too.
Assistant District Attorney Andrew Marco Belack said Mr. Tate had to go past the secure door — with which he could lock himself inside the bulletproof clerk’s booth — in order to continue shooting at the two men. It was only after he went to the doorway and “essentially unloaded his gun” on Mr. Smith that he locked himself inside the secure area.
“That could have been done at the first instance when the victims ran out of the store,” Mr. Belack said.
Judge Arnoni ultimately held both charges against Mr. Tate — homicide and aggravated assault — for trial. Formal arraignment is scheduled for Nov. 17.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.