For more than a decade, Robin Crumpton waited to be her family’s voice in court.

Her mother, Valorie Crumpton, and niece, Tionna Banks, couldn’t speak for themselves anymore.

They had been bludgeoned to death in May 2015 by Ms. Banks’ ex-boyfriend, Cesar Mazza. The ongoing argument between the former couple, authorities have said, stemmed from the fact that Ms. Banks, 19, refused to name their child after Mazza.

She had gotten a protection from abuse order against him, and she pressed charges when he assaulted her. A court hearing was set for May 6. Neither Ms. Banks nor Mazza showed.

Advertise with us

A day later, Ms. Banks and her 72-year-old grandmother, Valorie Crumpton, were found dead inside the older woman’s East Hills home. They had been stabbed multiple times and bludgeoned with a fireplace shovel over nearly every part of their bodies.

And so for more than 10 years, Robin Crumpton waited for her day in court — when the evidence against Mazza, now 35, would be laid out for a jury. For a decade, the District Attorney’s Office pursued the death penalty against Mazza. The DA dropped that bid last month at the request of the family. Earlier this week, just days before jury selection was set to begin, prosecutors and Mazza’s defense attorneys reached a plea agreement.

In exchange for pleading guilty to two counts of third-degree murder, Mazza was sentenced Wednesday to 30 to 60 years in prison. He receives credit for the 10 years he has spent awaiting trial in the Allegheny County Jail.

Ms. Crumpton was bereft — and irate.

“The system failed us completely,” she said. “A deal was made without us, and it was accepted without us.”

Advertise with us

The District Attorney’s Office acknowledged the family’s pain in a statement released shortly after the judge accepted the plea deal, noting that defense attorneys initially offered to plead in exchange for 25 to 50 years in prison.

“The family members advised that they objected to a plea to third degree,” according to the statement from the DA’s office.

Prosecutors accepted the defense counter offer of 30 to 60 years “after considering all the surrounding factual and evidentiary circumstances.”

“While we are aware of the family members’ objection to the plea agreement,” the statement said, “we have a responsibility to consider the evidence and procedural posture of a case and must make the difficult final decision on how to proceed.”

Given the chance by Common Pleas Judge Edward J. Borkowski to explain to the court the basis for the plea deal, Deputy District Attorney Ryan Kiray declined to do so: “Not at this time, your honor.”

Advertise with us

He had just finished detailing the brutalization Mazza had inflicted upon the women: Valorie Crumpton had nine distinct skull fractures, broken ribs, a broken leg and defensive wounds on her hands. Her granddaughter had been stabbed in the head, neck, back, chest, arm and thigh. Her skull was fractured in five places.

Mr. Kiray laid out the case that would have been presented if they had gone to trial. One witness would have testified that she had driven Mazza to Valorie Crumpton’s home on May 4, 2015, so he could pick up his newborn son. He returned around 15 minutes later with the child in tow and his clothes covered in stains.

Mazza’s sister would have testified that he showed up at their mother’s home unannounced that day. He had no baby supplies with him, and both he and the child were covered in blood. He showered, left the infant at the house, and didn’t return. He was arrested weeks later in New Jersey.

Mr. Kiray said Mazza’s DNA was found on the knife and fireplace shovel used in the attack.

A drawn-out case

Before the hearing began Wednesday, Mr. Kiray and Deputy District Attorney Jennifer Berosh approached Ms. Crumpton and her cousin, Rose Price, in the hallway outside Judge Borkowski’s courtroom.

Advertise with us

Ms. Crumpton said they offered the family no explanation for the plea deal.

“So who do we have to lean on? We don’t have the justice system to lean on,” she said. “Who do we lean on? Because we don’t have the DA’s office — they don’t give a damn about nobody.”

Instead, it was retired Pittsburgh police detective Bobby Shaw who sat with Ms. Crumpton, her cousin, Rose Price, and several other family members on a bench outside the courtroom before the hearing. He sat at the prosecution table with Mr. Kiray and Ms. Berosh as the victims’ family begged the judge not to accept the plea deal.

“We waited almost 11 years to have a case and hear our voices,” Ms. Crumpton said. “We were robbed of our chance to go to trial, to fight for our niece and mother. They can’t speak for themselves anymore.”

She had to be helped back to her seat. Her hands shook so hard she couldn’t put her typed-out statement back into its envelope.

Advertise with us

Mazza’s case went through six judges during the decade it was pending. It landed with Judge Borkowski late last year, and he set a firm trial date for Sept. 15.

The case dragged on for as long as it did in part because the death penalty was in play. But even for a death penalty case, it took an extraordinary amount of time to reach a resolution — “this went beyond that,” Judge Borkowski said ahead of sentencing. Mazza went through a string of defense attorneys during that time too.

The judge said that, absent the prosecutors’ explanation for agreeing to the plea deal, he surmised that the reason was likely because of evidentiary or witness-related issues.

Judge Borkowski said the circumstances that led to this point shouldn’t have happened.

“Someone should have put their procedural foot down long ago.”

Advertise with us

The judge asked to see Ms. Crumpton and Ms. Price in his chambers after the hearing. They said later that it was clear he, too, was dismayed with the way the case’s conclusion played out.

“He said, ‘I’m so apologetic, ’” Ms. Crumpton said. “And you could tell he was upset. I’ve never seen a judge do that before, but he said, ‘I’m so sorry.’ ”

Mr. Shaw, the retired detective, walked the women from the fifth-floor courtroom to a table and chairs on the fourth floor. He sat with Ms. Crumpton and Ms. Price and their victim advocate feet away from the district attorney’s office and talked with them about what had happened. He wrote down his phone number on the back of envelope and made Ms. Crumpton promise to call.

No one testified on Mazza’s behalf, but he did speak briefly before Judge Borkowski formally sentenced him. He said he regrets going to Valorie Crumpton’s house that day, and the killings were “never supposed to happen.”

“I’m so traumatized by the whole situation,” he said. “This is so hard and heavy upon me. I have to live with this the rest of my life.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Price said Mazza got off easy: “He’s still living his life. It might be behind bars, but he’s still alive.”

They said their family will do whatever they can to make sure Mazza serves the maximum sentence.

“If I’m not here, my children will fight. We’re going to keep him in jail. He’s going to do that 60,” Ms. Crumpton said. “My children will make sure that he stays in jail.”

Ms. Price then interjected: “The entire family.”