The tragic postscript to 3-year-old Bella Seachrist’s short life — her murder, the arrests, the court proceedings — ended quietly Tuesday when the final defendant in her case was sentenced to life in prison with no possibility of parole.

The Oakmont toddler would be nearing her ninth birthday if she were alive today, Deputy District Attorney Jennifer DiGiovanni noted. Instead, she said, the toddler was killed by those charged with her care before she could turn 4.

The sentencing hearing for 25-year-old Alexis Herrera, the sister of Bella’s stepmother, marked the end of court proceedings that lasted longer than Bella was alive.

In front of Common Pleas Judge Bruce R. Beemer, Ms. DiGiovanni gestured first to the Oakmont police officers in the jury box to her left, and then to Allegheny County police Detective Nicole DePaoli to her right at the prosecution table — the only people who ever showed up for Bella over the course of the proceedings.

Advertise with us

Once again, Ms. DiGiovanni said, there was no family there to speak on Bella’s behalf.

Such had been the case in every other court proceeding over the course of more than five years.

Her stepmother, Laura Ramriez, is serving a life sentence for masterminding the abuse that ultimately killed the brown-eyed toddler. Hundreds of text messages showed she encouraged her sister to treat the child with the same violence and contempt.

Her father, Jose Salazar-Ortiz, told jurors in 2023 that he knew his live-in girlfriend was abusing Bella. A jury convicted him of third-degree murder, and he was sentenced to up to 66 years in prison.

And neighbors said they didn’t know a little girl lived in the duplex on 10th Street until first responders carried her battered, emaciated body from the home on June 9, 2020.

Advertise with us

The hearing Tuesday was all but a formality: The judge found Herrera guilty of first-degree murder in March, nearly a year after she pleaded guilty to one general count of homicide.

Judge Beemer called it “one of the most disturbing, horrific, troubling cases” he had seen or presided over. Evidence presented during a degree-of-guilt hearing in January showed the family, including Herrera, routinely withheld from Bella food and water. She weighed 20 pounds when she died.

“What happened to that defenseless, scared, tortured 3-year-old child in that house is beyond shocking and horrifying,” he said.

Bella lived with family in North Carolina until she went to Oakmont to live with her father in September 2019, and investigators have said photos from the time showed a healthy, thriving toddler. When Herrera moved to Oakmont to live with her sister and her sister’s family, Ramriez recruited her to take part in the abusive contempt she had for the toddler, who police said was the result of an affair carried out by Salazar-Ortiz.

Eventually, authorities said, Herrera moved beyond a passive participant in the abuse — standing by while her sister doled out beatings and cruel punishments — to devising her own mistreatment.

Advertise with us

Photos Herrera sent to her sister while Ramriez was away showed Bella trapped inside the frame of a daybed and tied to the stairway banister, forced to stand on one leg with the other wedged between the spindles. She told police at one point that she was the one who gave Ramriez the initial idea to tie up the toddler.

Hundreds of other messages and photos between the sisters in the last months of Bella’s life showed near daily abuse: Bella tied and forced to stand hunched over in a closet, or forced to hold herself up on a toilet seat for hours. They called her an animal, a crackhead, or “Ebola.”

Herrera, Ms. DiGiovanni said, could have been Bella’s last line of defense if she’d chosen to take action: The weekend before the malnutrition and dehydration killed the toddler, Ramriez and Salazar-Ortiz went out of town to celebrate their anniversary. Herrera stayed in Oakmont, charged with caring for Bella and the couple’s other children.

“What is unforgivable to me is that Alexis Herrera was alone with Bella and those children for that last weekend of her life,” Ms. DiGiovanni said. “She had every chance to stand up and save that child’s life.”

Herrera instead took the opportunity to punch Bella in the face, Ms. DiGiovanni said, a reference to Herrera’s own admission to police that she had punched the girl just a few days before she died.

Advertise with us

Defense attorney Michael Machen argued during his client’s degree-of-guilt hearing in January that Herrera didn’t — and couldn’t — form the specific intent to kill. At the time, he presented experts that said that Herrera’s mental health diagnoses, including depression, anxiety, and borderline intellectual function — meant she wasn’t capable of forming such intent.

On Tuesday, Mr. Machen argued that life in prison without parole for his client — who he maintained didn’t have intent — was unconstitutional because it violated her Eighth Amendment protections against cruel and unusual punishment.

Judge Beemer was not swayed by the argument in January, and he was unmoved again on Tuesday. He said Bella’s death could have only happened with Herrera’s willingness — with her participation in the agreement “every day to deprive this child of food, of love, of any human kindness.”

Herrera, in a tearful statement to the court, said she was remorseful.

“I never wanted any of this to happen,” she said. “I’m sorry. I have to live with this every day of my life, and that’s probably the worst punishment anyone could give me.”

Advertise with us

That may be the case now, Judge Beemer told her, but it wasn’t during the months she helped abuse Bella to death.

“That remorse certainly wasn’t present in January, in February, in March, in April, in May,” he said, “and certainly not in June when … medics were trying to save a child whittled down to 19 pounds.”