Tedra Allen said she felt immense pride when her nephew, Antoine Williams, told her he learned to walk away during volatile and violent arguments with his girlfriend.

Now, she said she’s haunted by those words after Williams, 30, was shot multiple times in the back by Charlotte Hill during a fatal domestic dispute outside an East Hills apartment complex in November 2023. Hill, 37, pleaded guilty in November to third-degree murder.

“He put his hands up and turned his back on his executioner,” Ms. Allen said during Hill’s sentencing hearing Thursday morning.

After hours of emotional statements from friends and relatives, Commons Pleas Judge Edward Borkowski sentenced Hill to 15-30 years in prison. When he announced the sentence, Hill’s mother, Carmen Anthony, collapsed in the courtroom.

Advertise with us

“I was a good mom,” she sobbed from the hallway as relatives comforted her.

About two dozen friends and relatives of Hill and Williams packed the small courtroom for the hearing, where both sides spoke of the couple’s tumultuous relationship and the ongoing impact of the fatal shooting.

When Hill entered the courtroom wearing a neon green inmate uniform, her hands shackled to her waist, she smiled at family members who filled the right side of the gallery. Some offered small waves back.

The court heard from Williams’ relatives, some of whom sent in written statements. As they spoke, some members of Hill's family subtly rocked in their seats. Hill herself spent much of the time with her head bowed, looking down at the wooden table.

“I’ll never get to hear his voice again or see him pop into my room,” a letter from Antoine Williams Sr., the victim’s father, read.

Advertise with us

The court also heard from about a half-dozen of Hill’s friends and relatives.

“During the most difficult times of my life, she stood by my side without hesitation,” said her longtime friend, Chantel Pizaro.

Hill’s 17-year-old son, Ja’Keill Hill, addressed the judge.

“My mom is the most caring person I know. … I need her at home,” he said. “My mom would never do something like this if she wasn’t in danger.”

Ms. Anthony, said her daughter’s youngest son still doesn’t understand what happened to his mom.

Advertise with us

“I ask the court to give mercy to my daughter,” she said to Judge Borkowski.

Hill also spoke briefly, apologizing to both families.

“I’m very sorry for the decision I made. … I’m very sorry for the reality we have to live in,” she said.

Ultimately, Judge Borkowski wasn’t swayed.

“He was shot in the back trying to leave,” the judge said.