With tears and wails of both anguish and relief, family members of Makeida Thompson on Friday continued to mourn her death while they celebrated the first-degree murder conviction jurors handed down against her killer.

Terrence Washington, 40, faces a mandatory life sentence without the possibility of parole for the 2020 killing of Ms. Thompson in front of his grandmother and the couple’s 1-year-old son.

“That he will never see the light of day is a blessing,” Ms. Thompson’s older sister, Dawnisha Thompson, said outside the third-floor Common Pleas courtroom.

Her sister loved all things Steelers and football, she said, and she was a good mom.

Advertise with us

“My sister can finally rest.”

The jury of seven men and five women deliberated for about three hours Friday afternoon, signaling about 3 p.m. they had reached a verdict.

Nearly a dozen of Ms. Thompson’s family members attended each day of testimony in the case, which began Tuesday. Common Pleas Judge Beth Lazzara warned the courtroom ahead of the jury’s return that they must have no outward reactions regardless of the outcome.

Jurors were faced with two nearly identical versions of what happened Nov. 10, 2020, in the East Liberty living room of Washington’s mother.

In the version laid out by Deputy District Attorney Ryan Kiray, Washington was a father enraged by the protection from abuse order Ms. Thompson took out against him and by the custody and child support hearings she intended to initiate.

Advertise with us

He pointed to text messages Washington sent in the days and weeks before the shooting: He told Ms. Thompson not to talk about “that court [expletive].” He told her she had two strikes against her and, in another, he told her that was “strike three.”

“Heaven hath no rage like love turned hatred, nor hell a fury like a woman scorned,” Mr. Kiray told jurors in his closing argument, using an oft-misquoted line from the 17th-century play “The Mourning Bride.”

He called this case one of the former that the defense wanted to portray as one of the latter.

Washington’s mother, Tirzha Moore, was in her kitchen when the shooting happened. Darlene Washington, his grandmother, sat across the room with the baby on her lap. Both testified against him to open the trial.

Mr. Kiray recounted Ms. Washington’s testimony: There was no argument, no aggression on Ms. Thompson’s part. Her grandson, she said, just started shooting.

Advertise with us

“She was unequivocal from the very beginning … she looked up and he just started shooting,” he said, emphasizing each of the last three words.

Defense attorney Thomas N. Farrell told jurors that his client shot Ms. Thompson to save his own life.

Washington testified a day earlier that he had called Ms. Thompson to his mother’s house that day to talk through their issues like adults. He said that as she sat on the couch, she turned toward him, mouthed an expletive, and then turned as though reaching for the pistol he knew she kept holstered to her right side.

“He never intended to kill her,” Mr. Farrell said once, twice, a third time. “He testified warts and all — warts and all, ladies and gentlemen.”

The defense attorney had tried to poke holes in the case laid out by Mr. Kiray — numerous officers and medics and at least one neighbor walked through the crime scene in the immediate aftermath; Ms. Washington was distracted and didn’t see Ms. Thompson’s movements right before the shooting; and Ms. Thompson had sent her own menacing text messages in the months prior.

Advertise with us

“I don’t have to explain anything, I just have to stand here with my hands in my pockets,” Mr. Farrell told jurors, a reference to the fact that the burden of proof in the case falls on the prosecution. “But I strong suggest that everything he told you was the truth.”

He told jurors in his closing argument that the shooting was a clear-cut case of self-defense or, at most, voluntary manslaughter, which would have required jurors to find Washington’s belief his life was in danger was unreasonable.

Mr. Kiray, in his own closing, urged jurors to return the verdict that they ultimately did: first-degree murder. That verdict meant jurors believed the shooting was premeditated and done with specific intent.

He pointed to four spots toward the back left portion of his head, mimicking the places where Ms. Thompson was shot.

“This shot, this shot, this shot, this shot — that, ladies and gentleman, is specific intent,” Mr. Kiray said.

Judge Lazzara said that although sentencing will be a formality because of the mandatory sentence, she wanted Ms. Thompson’s family to have the opportunity to address the court. It is scheduled for June 25.