A McKeesport police officer is suing the city and the mayor, alleging he’s been passed over for promotions for years based on his race and that officials retaliated against him when he filed a discrimination complaint and voiced support for another Black officer who’d been fired.
The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission ruled last year there was reasonable cause to believe McKeesport not only discriminated against veteran officer Julian Thomas when it came to promotions, but also meted out unfairly harsh discipline because of his race and in retaliation for his support of a fired officer.
EEOC investigators said they found that the actions weren’t just limited to Officer Thomas; rather, the commission ruled the city of McKeesport, referred to in the commission’s letters simply as the “respondent,” engaged in a pattern of discrimination against Black and female officers for years.
In an emailed statement, McKeesport solicitor J. Jason Elash declined to comment on the pending case but noted “we vehemently deny the allegations contained in the complaint.
Mayor Mike Cherepko called the case “fallacy” and took aim at Officer Thomas directly.
“There is absolutely no truth to any of these allegations whatsoever,” the mayor said in a statement. “However, I would expect nothing less from Mr. Thomas, whose own conduct is unbecoming of a police officer.”
He pointed to a previous EEOC complaint that was referred to the Department of Justice, which chose not to file suit.
In a letter to Officer Thomas, a DOJ attorney wrote that while it would not file a lawsuit, “This should not be taken to mean that the Department of Justice had made a judgment as to whether or not your charge is meritorious.” The letter notified the officer of his right to sue.
An attorney for Officer Thomas could not immediately be reached.
The allegations originate from two separate EEOC complaints Officer Thomas filed against the city and police department.
In one complaint, Officer Thomas alleged he was passed over for a promotion to the rank of sergeant because of his race. In the other, he alleged minor damage to his police cruiser resulted in a 30-day suspension that he believed was retaliation for his first EEOC complaint and for voicing his support for Candace Tyler, a Black officer who at the time was suing the city over her termination.
In a determination letter dated July 29, Pittsburgh EEOC Director Deborah Kane wrote that the city has regularly skirted its collective bargaining agreement with officers in relying on the mayor’s “subjective criteria” for promotions as opposed to an application process and civil service testing.
“Evidence further revealed [the city] has engaged in a pattern of promoting white male police officers at a significantly higher rate than Black or female officers,” Ms. Kane wrote.
Ms. Kane noted in the letter that the pattern wasn’t limited by race: The investigation showed that no women who were considered just as qualified — if not more qualified — than their male counterparts received rank promotions or were promoted to the K-9 unit since at least 2005.
Officer Thomas, who has been with the McKeesport police since 2009 and a full-time officer since 2014, alleged that for years the department has failed to post ranking officer openings when they become available, failed to conduct civil service testing for those positions, and never held candidate interviews for rank positions.
The issue came to a head in December 2021 when, according to Officer Thomas, four white officers were promoted to positions of rank without interviews, posting the open positions, or civil service testing. Officer Thomas wrote that he was at least as qualified as the white candidates, and he filed an EEOC grievance.
A month later, Officer Thomas wrote a letter in support of Ms. Tyler’s EEOC grievance, which she filed after her termination in October 2021. The letter explained Officer Thomas’ belief that women and minorities within the department weren’t afforded the same opportunities as the white men in the department.
Months later, Officer Thomas scraped the side of his vehicle against the pole. When he noticed the extent of the damage the next day, he “promptly reported the damage to his immediate supervisor.” He alleged Mr. Cherepko, the mayor, and then-Chief Adam Alfer extrapolated the incident Officer Thomas “[failing] to report a serious incident.” He was suspended for 30 days, accused of not being forthcoming or truthful.
Officer Thomas, in separate EEOC complaint, alleged the 30-day suspension was based on discrimination and retaliation. The EEOC investigation found the same, with Ms. Kane writing that evidence showed white officers who engaged in similar or worse misconduct “were not subjected to lengthy suspensions.”
Again, the EEOC found that such behavior on the part of the city wasn’t limited to Officer Thomas. Ms. Kane wrote the evidence showed Black and female officers were disciplined more severely than their white male counterparts.
The EEOC letter gave the example of a female officer who received a 15-day suspension for an off-duty infraction involving alcohol. A male officer who had a similar off-duty infraction was suspended for five days. In another example, a Black officer was suspended for 10 days for an excessive use of force but a white officer received a five-day suspension for the same thing — even though the white officer didn’t follow proper reporting procedures.
When the EEOC determines there’s evidence of discrimination, the commission is obligated to try to engage the two sides — in this case, the City of McKeesport and Officer Thomas — in what’s known as conciliation. Conciliation, according to commission procedures, is a process to try to resolve the complaint through an informal agreement
In a Dec. 10 letter, the Department of Justice notified Officer Thomas that conciliation had been “unsuccessful,” and he had the right to sue the city. His lawsuit was filed March 7.
The lawsuit is seeking a promotion for Officer Thomas when an opening arises and for front pay, back pay, lost benefits and other damages. The lawsuit also asks the court to deem the city liable for racial discrimination and retaliation — and Mr. Cherepko held liable for “aiding and abetting racial discrimination and retaliation.”
The EEOC received 88,531 complaints in 2024, and data shows a vast majority of grievances filed with the commission are dismissed for lack of reasonable cause — meaning the commission finds insufficient evidence of discrimination.
The commission received around 30,270 race-based grievances in 2024 and resolved just under 30,000 of them. Of those resolved, 70% were dismissed. In just under 14.5% — or 4,257 — of cases, the commission found in favor of the person filing the grievance.
The breakdown was relatively similar for retaliation-based complaints filed with the EEOC. Of just under 50,000 resolved complaints, 62% were dismissed and just under 18% were favorable to the complainant.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.