There was no one specific action Alexis Herrera carried out in the six months between her arrival in Oakmont in January 2020 and later that spring that killed Bella Seachrist, Common Pleas Judge Bruce Beemer opined Friday.

Rather, he said, it was the culmination of each act of abuse, torture and neglect the 3-year-old suffered at the hands of Herrera and her sister.

And each one of those acts of abuse, torture and neglect were deliberate and intentional, the judge said Friday in finding Herrera guilty of first-degree murder in the June 9, 2020, death of her step-niece.

“The malice, the wickedness, the cruelty, the hardness of heart — the utter disdain and contempt shown for this child — is the very definition of maliciousness,” Judge Beemer said. “It’s hard to imagine a child treated with more contempt.”

Advertise with us

Herrera, now 25, pleaded guilty last year to a count of general homicide for her role in Bella’s death. Judge Beemer was to determine to what degree Herrera was guilty: Did her actions constitute involuntary manslaughter, third-degree murder, or first-degree murder?

The question, he said, was this: “Did Alexis Herrera possess the specific intent to kill this child?”

Yes, he ruled Friday.

Her actions, he said, were a unique type of cold and deliberate — “the sort of premeditation and deliberation that separates first-degree murder from other killings.”

Defense experts had tried to paint Herrera as a young woman barely functioning — who relied on, was beholden to, and feared her older sister and Bella’s step-mother, Laura Ramriez.

Advertise with us

Judge Beemer took issue with the fact that the defense experts examined Herrera in a vacuum — they relied solely on their interviews with and texting of the defendant. The prosecution’s forensic psychiatrist, he said, used all of that information as well as Herrera’s police interviews, the evidence in the case, and the criminal complaint.

Herrera, the judge said, had the capacity to, within less than an hour of Bella’s death, delete any text messages that mentioned the toddler or the words death or dying.

“She had the wherewithal to wipe her phone of information that could be used against her,” he said, calling that a particularly relevant piece of information when coupled with the fact that Herrera intentionally misled police in the initial aftermath of Bella’s death.

She didn’t tell police she was powerless to stop the abuse, he said — she told them she didn’t see any abuse. She said Bella was happy and healthy. She just bruised easily.

He called the case replete with instances in which Herrera could have paused to reflect, to change her behavior, to do something. But she didn’t. He pointed to the fact that the weekend before Bella died, Ramriez and Bella’s father, Jose Eduardo Salazar-Ortiz, went out of state to celebrate their anniversary.

Advertise with us

In dozens of text messages between Ramriez and Herrera that weekend, Herrera sent photos of the abuse to which she was subjecting Bella — tied to an overturned daybed and forced to stand in the box spring in one, while another showed her tied to a banister, forced to stand on one leg while the other was twisted unnaturally through the spindles.

A jury in 2023 convicted Ramriez of first degree murder. She is serving a mandatory life sentence. Salazar-Ortiz was convicted of third-degree murder and Judge Beemer sentenced him to 33 to 66 years in prison.

Sentencing is set for June 5, though it will be more of formality, as first-degree murder in Pennsylvania carries a mandatory life sentence.

Attorneys on both sides declined to comment following the hearing.