A Pittsburgh man already serving life in prison on federal drug and gun charges received another nine years Monday for punching his attorney in the head during trial preparations in 2022, according to the U.S. Attorney’s Office.

A day later, the Third Circuit Court upheld James Byrd’s 2022 conviction and life sentence, finding the District Court did not violate Byrd’s rights when he was barred from the courtroom and not allowed to represent himself.

Byrd was arguing with his court-appointed attorney during a break in jury selection for his July 2022 trial when he lunged and punched the attorney in the back of the head. He was indicted on contempt and assault charges in March 2023, having already been found guilty and sentenced to life in prison in the original case.

Byrd, 47, was convicted of the contempt and assault charges last year, and he was sentenced Monday by U.S. District Judge Robert J. Colville. Acting U.S. Attorney Troy Rivetti called the attack “an assault upon the rule of law.”

Advertise with us

The July 18, 2022, attack on attorney R. Damien Schorr led to Byrd being tried in absentia, and U.S. District Judge Cathy Bissoon at the time denied Mr. Schorr’s request to be removed from the case.

Byrd appealed his 2022 conviction, alleging the District Court erred by revoking his right to represent himself, denying Mr. Schorr’s motion to withdraw as Byrd’s counsel, barring him from the courtroom, and choosing prosecutors’ jury instructions over those proposed by Byrd.

Circuit Judge Cheryl Ann Krause wrote that a defendant’s right to self-representation can be revoked if he becomes obstructionist, hostile, disruptive, or engages in other misconduct.

“Here, Byrd’s conduct far surpasses this threshold,” Judge Krause wrote, pointing to his refusal to participate in pretrial hearings, his abusive and explicit language, and threatening comments he made to the judge.

While an attorney can withdraw or be removed from a case when a court deems there is “good cause” — including, among other things, there is a “complete breakdown of communication” between attorney and client — Judge Krause noted that good cause doesn’t exist “when the breakdown in the attorney-client relationship is entirely [the defendant’s] fault.”

Advertise with us

Byrd’s removal from the courtroom was warranted, according to the judge’s opinion, after he continued his disorderly, disruptive conduct.

Indeed, Judge Krause wrote, Byrd was invited to return to the courtroom if he could conduct himself properly, but Byrd refused each day to come to court, “seemingly with the goal of manufacturing a mistrial.” Byrd was allowed back into the courtroom to testify in his own defense.

His issue with the jury instructions, the Third Circuit ruled, was essentially a matter of semantics, and the judge made no error in using those proposed by prosecutor.

Byrd was indicted on drug and gun charges in 2017, with a federal grand jury finding he’d illegally possessed a pistol and ammunition and intended to deal cocaine, crack, heroin and marijuana. The indictment was related to a 2015 incident in McKeesport in which Byrd threatened to shoot up a house. His criminal history up to that point included convictions for robbery, kidnapping, and aggravated assault.

In a separate case in the Court of Common Pleas, Byrd was sentenced to 49 to 98 years in prison after a jury convicted him of nearly a dozen charges connected to the 2015 rape and assault of a former paramour.

He’d previously served 12 years in prison in Ohio charges of robbery, kidnapping, and burglary. He was released on parole in October 2014 and arrested in the McKeesport incident in February 2015. Byrd accumulated more than 70 misconduct reports at the Allegheny County Jail between his arrest and sentencing on the federal drug charges in early 2023.