An investigation into deplorable conditions at a housing complex has snowballed into a probe surrounding the ownership group behind nearly a dozen subsidized properties in the region that led to new charges Friday in connection with Palisades Plaza in Rankin.

A public nuisance charge for “life-threatening” conditions was filed by detectives with the District Attorney’s Office against the ownership group behind the eight-building complex that authorities said failed a federal inspection late last year.

The charge is filed against the limited liability corporation known as Palisades Apts, which is linked to the same three men who own the troubled MonView Heights in West Mifflin.

Those men — Jonathan Liani, Moshe Silbur, and Frederick Schulman — face a litany of charges in Allegheny County related to the alleged theft of rent and federal funds meant to keep up the West Mifflin property. The men are associated with the company NB Affordable.

Advertise with us

In a statement, District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. implied that this counterpart in Westmoreland County could be looking into properties there owned by the same group. Previous criminal complaints against the three men indicate they own Valley Royal Court in New Kensington through an LLC set up in the same name.

“A major role of this office is to defend those who cannot defend themselves,” Mr. Zappala said. “We are fortunate to have Westmoreland County join our efforts in seeking justice for some of our most vulnerable and underserved communities.”

Melanie Jones, a spokesperson for Westmoreland District Attorney Nicole Ziccarelli, said no charges have been filed against any subsidized housing owners in that county.

“I am in support of the endeavors of the Allegheny County District Attorney’s Office, and we work well together across county lines,” Ms. Ziccarelli said in a statement. “DA Zappala has identified a major problem that intersects with criminal justice, and it comes down to protecting public safety.

“Everyone is entitled to safe and equitable housing and if a problem arises that is jeopardizing the safety and well-being of the residents I represent, we will address it appropriately,” she said.

Advertise with us

In regard to Rankin’s Palisades Plaza, a December inspection by officials with the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development “generated a lengthy report” that cited “life-threatening deficiencies that require immediate correction,” according to the complaint against the LLC. The housing complex scored a zero out of 100 on the inspection.

Authorities alleged a slew of public safety-related calls related to the property — nearly 300 in 2024 — that ranged from trespassing and fights to shots fired and domestic violence. The Eastern Regional Mon Valley Police Department, which covers Rankin, responded to 32 calls in the first two months of this year.

The complaint detailed deplorable conditions throughout the complex: shattered windows that left shards of glass littering the property, broken door hinges, raw sewage on the ground and an entire building with inoperable hallway lights.

According to the complaint, ERMVP Officer Christopher Mosesso first noticed raw sewage backing up through a ground-level access in August. As of last week, the sewage backup remained.

A representative for Winn Residential, a management company contracted by NB Affordable to oversee 15 properties in the area, told investigators she found the property in “critical condition” when her company took over in August.

Advertise with us

Maureen Cassley, Winn’s regional vice president, said numerous unpaid rents had accumulated by the time her company took over, and there had been no evictions in at least a year. Utility services across the complex had been turned off because of unpaid bills.

She said there was no money for maintenance or upkeep, according to the complaint, and “bedbugs, roaches, mice, and rats … were widespread.” Previous pest control services lapsed because of unpaid invoices. She said the initial focus had to be on restoring utilities “to ensure residents had basic living conditions.”

The company tried to end its contract with NB Affordable in September “when it became clear that NB lacked the desire to confront the issues facing residents and the resources to fund even the most basic operations,” Winn spokesman Ed Cafasso said in a statement Saturday morning. Winn agreed to stay on, he said, until new property managers could take over, and the company’s contract with Palisades Plaza and other NB Affordable properties ended Jan. 31.

“The appalling issues confronting residents of these communities existed long before we were engaged by the owners and, unfortunately, will continue well into the future without immediate intervention and significant capital investment,” Mr. Cafasso said.

Indeed, the criminal complaint included statements from borough tax collector Carl Lewis, who indicated the issues far predate NB Affordable’s takeover. Mr. Lewis wrote that he’s lived and worked in the borough for 14 years and, “From the very beginning, this property has been riddled with crime and unsafe living conditions.” He wrote that there is no security and no regular means to protect residents.

Advertise with us

Palisades Plaza, MonView Heights and multiple other properties in the region were all part of a massive sale by the Allegheny Housing Rehabilitation Corporation to the owners of NB Affordable in February 2023. Authorities have said the ownership group formed a separate LLC for each property.

The theft charges against Mr. Liani, Silber and Schulman stem from an investigation that began last year into MonView Heights.

A Housing Assistance Payments contract from HUD was signed by Schulman the day of the purchase, according to the complaint. That contract dictated that the owner would request a specific government subsidy based on resident needs, and the owner had to attest that, to the best of their knowledge, the “dwelling units are in decent, safe and sanitary condition.”

Authorities said an analysis of bank records showed that the Mon View LLC contracted with NB Affordable as the asset management group for MonView Heights and the other properties purchased in 2023. NB Affordable is also known as Rhodium Capital Advisors, which is controlled by Silber.

Investigators alleged that the three men listed as owners misused HUD taxpayer dollars: Money that should have gone toward making the properties safe and sanitary instead went to bank accounts controlled by related businesses owned by Silber.

Advertise with us

All three men are scheduled for a preliminary hearing March 7 in front of District Judge Richard D. Olasz Jr. in West Mifflin.

Silber and Schulman were already awaiting sentencing on federal fraud charges out of New Jersey. Those charges center on an Ohio property called the Williamsburg of Cincinnati, a sprawling complex of apartments and townhomes touted as “uncommonly good living.”

Schulman and Silber bought the property in 2019 through Rhodium Capital Advisors, authorities have said. The men acquired the Cincinnati property for $70 million but used a stolen identity and fake paperwork to present their lender with an inflated sales contract worth more than $95 million.

The fraud came to light last year, and the feds filed fraud charges against Schulman, Silber and a third conspirator on July 9. Silber immediately pleaded guilty to one count of conspiracy to commit wire fraud in exchange for the feds dropping the other charges against him, including wire fraud and identity theft.

Schulman and the third man involved, Chaim “Eli” Puretz, pleaded guilty to the same charge a month later.