Retail theft has risen dramatically in Allegheny County since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020, part of a statewide and national trend.
Cases increased across Pennsylvania by 53% from 2021 to 2023, following years in decline during the pandemic, according to a release from PA Courts InfoShare.

The spike was even higher in Allegheny County, where retail crimes rose 91.4% in 2023 to 5,157 reports, compared to 2,694 in 2021.
Pennsylvania’s retail crime woes are part of an emerging national trend.
Shoplifting across America in the first six months of 2024 was 10% higher than the first six months of 2023 and 24% higher than the pre-pandemic baseline in 2019, said Ernesto Lopez, a senior research specialist at the Council on Criminal Justice, an independent think tank in Washington, D.C.
“Retail theft is becoming a national crisis, hurting businesses in every state and the communities they serve,” said Neil Bradley, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce’s executive vice president and chief policy officer. “We call on policymakers to tackle this problem head-on before it gets further out of control. No store should have to close because of theft."
Audrey Guskey, an associate professor of marketing at Duquesne University, said she was shocked that Allegheny County reported the highest increase, even ahead of much larger Philadelphia.
“It's a good place to live, and to have it be considered crime-ridden is frustrating and discouraging for us,” she said.
Thieves are more likely to steal from large corporations they believe can more easily cover their losses than locally owned businesses that are often struggling to stay afloat, Ms. Guskey said.
“They feel that they’re not harming anyone, they’re going after big business, corporate America,” she said. “A lot of people salute that and encourage that because their feeling is that prices are too high, they’re gouging us.”
But in the end, all shoppers will pay for the thefts. Many of those same large stores simply write off a percent of their sales as stolen merchandise and raise prices to make up the difference, she said.
“You’re looking at a lot of money that we are spending that sadly we’re covering for criminals,” she said.
The nationwide increase comes at a time when retailers are utilizing many anti-theft measures to protect merchandise, including locked display cases, Mr. Lopez said.
The surge in numbers could be due, in part, to increased reporting of stolen goods by businesses, he said.
“Someone can shoplift an item, and it's just not detected until inventory,” he said. “Until they start crunching their own numbers on their side internally, they may notice that there's a loss.”
Brentwood police Chief Adam Zeppuhar said he had noticed a major increase in retail theft within his community, which has a population of just under 11,000. Brentwood has fielded 97 reports of retail theft since October 2021, with 47 of those in 2024.
Chief Zeppuhar said Brentwood’s Giant Eagle location on Towne Square Way has been targeted by thieves because it is one of the largest businesses in the borough.
Giant Eagle employs third-party security guards focused on loss prevention and reducing the number of thefts, he said.
“They'll detain the person, and we go and assist and file appropriate charges as necessary or assist in any kind of identification,” he said.
Chief Zeppuhar also has noticed a correlation between opioid abuse and retail theft-related arrests, a trend that Ms. Guskey said is backed by national statistics.
“Retail theft is a lot of times, unfortunately, to support chemical dependency [or] some sort of vice,” he said.
Ross Deputy Chief Brian Kohlhepp said his department began assigning an officer to investigate retail theft cases in an attempt to “bring some of these people to the courts.”
Some thieves are more skilled than others, making them harder to apprehend, he said.
“Some people just walk in, pick up things, and walk out … some of them use systems or techniques to try to stay a little more incognito,” he said.
Fewer than half of accused retail thieves nationally are actually convicted, Ms. Guskey said, which may be encouraging some to steal who think they can get away with it.
“The reason that a lot of people are taking things is that they feel they're entitled to it. It’s accepted in our culture,” she said.
The best way to discourage theft, Deputy Chief Kohlhepp said, is for employees to remain visible in stores and approach customers to offer help finding items.
“You can do all this under the caveat of customer service, but what has been shown to reduce retail theft is when people are engaged in a conversation with a store employee,” he said.
That kind of visibility is more difficult during the holiday season, a time when stores are crowded and customers are harder to keep track of, Ms. Guskey said.
“A lot of times that watchful eye isn't there,” she said.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.