ALTOONA, Pa. — Three days after a health care CEO was gunned down in a brazen shooting in Manhattan, Dave Kenawell was walking out of a Sheetz 280 miles away when something caught his eye.

He saw a man who looked remarkably like the shooter, whose face was captured on surveillance video throughout New York after the Dec. 4 killing and widely distributed to media outlets.

“I was walking out and I just happened to look over at this guy standing there and I said to myself, he looks very familiar,” Mr. Kenawell said. “I had seen the TV in the last couple days and I turned around … looked at his shoes, his coat and stuff and was, like, that looks like the guy. 

“I almost jokingly went up and said, ‘Hey, you might want to change your clothes. You look like that guy on TV.’ ”

Advertise with us

Mr. Kenawell said he didn’t approach the man or initially call police because he doubted he would actually cross paths with the subject of a massive New York City manhunt in Altoona, the Blair County city of about 42,000 where the convenience store chain Sheetz was founded. 

“I was like, ‘Nah, that can’t be him,’ we’re in Pennsylvania,” Mr. Kenawell said. “Then, this morning, I see he gets caught five blocks from my house at McDonald’s.”

Read More

Luigi Mangione, 26, was arrested Monday morning after a customer at the McDonald’s on East Plank Road — across the street from where Mr. Kenawell saw him two days earlier — recognized his face from photos being circulated by the New York Police Department and told an employee, who called local police.

He was sitting at a table wearing a blue mask, with a laptop in front of him and a backpack at his feet, police said,

When Altoona police Officers Tyler Frye and Joe Detwiller approached and began questioning him, he pulled down his mask and handed the officers a New Jersey ID with the name “Mark Rosario.” Asked if he had been to New York recently, he “started to shake,” according to a criminal complaint.

Advertise with us

Officer Frye, who officials said has been on the job for six months, said at a press conference Monday evening that he didn’t expect to play a part in bringing the New York City suspect into custody.

“It feels good to get a guy like that off the street,” Officer Frye said. “He was very cooperative. He didn’t give us any problems.”

Gov. Josh Shapiro commended Officer Frye.

"He acted with smarts, and he acted with calm,” he said. “You know, safety often turns on the strength of the relationship between the community and law enforcement. We have that strong relationship here in Altoona, and it was proven here today."

Mr. Mangione has been charged with forgery and firearms offenses and was being held in state prison in Huntingdon, Pa. He was later charged in New York for the fatal shooting of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson.

Advertise with us

Mr. Kenawell said it was chilling to hear that the man being sought for “lying in wait” for Mr. Thompson as the insurance executive crossed the street to a conference in Midtown Manhattan before shooting him multiple times in the back was found in Altoona.

“I think it’s pretty crazy,” he said. “I almost went and talked to him.”

Connections to Pittsburgh

Police said they are early in their investigation but believe Mr. Mangione traveled across the state from Philadelphia to Pittsburgh in the days after the Dec. 4 shooting as police launched a massive manhunt for the gunman.

Mr. Shapiro specifically mentioned Pittsburgh in answering follow-up questions during Monday evening’s news conference.

“We would like to hear from any Pennsylvanian — any Pittsburgher — who had any sightings or any dealings with the individual,” he said.

Advertise with us

Anyone with tips can call 800-472-8477, Mr. Shapiro said.

Mr. Shapiro stressed that violence can never be used to address political differences or to prove an ideological point, referencing the July 13 attempted assassination of President-elect Donald Trump at a rally in Butler County.

“That is not what we do in a civilized society,” he said. “That was true in Butler, it was true in NYC, it’s true anywhere. That is not how you make progress in this country. The suspect who shot at that CEO and killed that CEO, is a coward, and not a hero.

“That is an important lesson coming out of Pennsylvania and it is one that I think the rest of the country needs to hear as well.”

By Monday afternoon, the McDonald’s restaurant where Mr. Mangione was arrested was relatively empty, save for a few employees and a gathering of media and TV crews in the parking lot. Employees inside declined to talk.

Advertise with us

Following Mr. Mangione’s arraignment, some residents remained outside on the sidewalk in front of the Blair County Courthouse in Hollidaysburg, watching local, state and New York City law enforcement officials file into their vehicles.

Ken Brumbaugh, 25, who grew up in Hollidaysburg and was back visiting family, said the incident was unlike anything he ever imagined coming to the small borough of less than 6,000 people.

“It’s really surreal,” he said. “When you watch national media, you think of New York City, Atlanta, Chicago and all these major cities having something like this. For him to just be caught in Altoona, five minutes away, then being arraigned in little Hollidaysburg is really surprising.”

Mr. Brumbaugh said he was also shocked watching officers usher Mr. Mangione through the back entrance of the court.

“When you were behind the courthouse and we saw everybody kind of trying to shield him and get him inside … and seeing the NYPD, FBI, and governor is even here and just how everything is conducted and how fast-paced it is,” he said. “It’s really eye-opening and surreal to see how much this is impacting everybody across the country.”