In front of a packed courtroom and exasperated judge all prepared to move forward with the scheduled court proceedings Wednesday morning, a man convicted of gunning down an off-duty police officer in Blawnox in 2022 fired his attorney and asked for a new one, forcing the sentencing hearing to a halt.

Common Pleas Judge Jill Rangos was short on patience with Kevin McSwiggen from the start, noting she had tried to resolve the lingering court issues a week ago but McSwiggen refused to come to court — something he denied and tried to argue before Judge Rangos cut him off.

“I will not allow you to run to proceedings,” she said. “That is my job.”

McSwiggen, 42, was convicted in July of killing Charles “Chuckie” Stipetich after a purported road-rage incident.

Advertise with us

Defense attorney Casey White told the judge that his client had asked him to file motions that he could not in good conscience file — motions "that he did not feel had merit."

“Mr. McSwiggen,” Judge Rangos told the convicted killer, “I think you misunderstand criminal procedure.”

She told him that such motions can and should be filed after sentencing, and his right to file those motions would not end after sentencing proceedings.

When McSwiggen tried to argue with the judge, she cut him off.

“Stop talking now,” she said, and when McSwiggen forged on, she repeated it: “Stop talking now. Stop talking now.”

Advertise with us

Post-sentence motions must be filed within 10 days of sentencing, and McSwiggen indicated that that would not be enough time for him to acquire trial transcripts and craft his motion. He claimed Mr. White told him he could not and would not file those motions on McSwiggen’s behalf.

“Mr. White will do what I tell him to do,” the judge said.

A jury convicted McSwiggen in July of third-degree murder for killing Stipetich, an off-duty Oakdale police officer, outside his Fountain Street home July 3, 2022. McSwiggen had followed the 23-year-old for more than a mile on Route 28 after he purported Stipetich cut him off.

McSwiggen confronted Stipetich, whose father, Charles P. Stipetich, came outside and tried to intervene. McSwiggen pulled a gun and shot Stipetich, who was able to return fire before he collapsed. McSwiggen and his attorney have maintained the shooting was in self-defense.

While Mr. White had filed a motion to withdraw from the case, the judge was not obligated to accept it.

Advertise with us

Instead, McSwiggen told Judge Rangos he was firing Mr. White and wanted a court-appointed public defender.

The judge explained in a multitude of ways why that was unnecessary, including pointing out that a new attorney would be coming into the case with no in-depth knowledge of the case or trial.

“I can’t have a counselor that I cannot trust,” McSwiggen said.

Deputy District Attorney Lisa Carey objected to the postponement, pointing out the dozen or so friends and family members who had come to court to give victim impact statements ahead of sentencing. One person, Ms. Carey said, flew in from out of state.

One of those family members uttered an expletive in frustration.

Advertise with us

Judge Rangos said her hands were tied, as the defendant has a right to an attorney for every level of proceedings.

“In 22 years … I have never been put in this position before,” she said.

Stipetich’s family members were frustrated but understood that it was McSwiggen’s right to have an attorney.

“I think it’s pretty obviously intentional on the defendant’s part in order to try to delay sentencing,” said Jim Hankle, an attorney and friend who spoke on behalf of the Stipetich family.

He called the whole ordeal incredibly frustrating but said Judge Rangos had little choice in the matter.

“He has put her in a precarious situation,” he said, adding: “I don’t think he’s done himself any favors.”