The owner of multiple resale businesses has been convicted in Pittsburgh federal court in connection to the buying and selling of $4.3 million worth of goods that had been shoplifted by drug addicts, the U.S. Attorney’s office in Pittsburgh announced Wednesday.

Durrell Waters, 41, of Pittsburgh, was indicted on one count of conspiracy and four counts of money laundering in 2020, according to a release.  A jury took five hours to convict the defendant in front of District Judge Mark R. Hornak.

A sentencing date will be determined by the court, according to the release.

Anthony Costanzo, 35, of Carnegie, was Waters’ co-conspirator and co-owner of the different operations, according to the release. He pleaded guilty to four counts of engaging in monetary transactions involving property from an illegal act in July.

Advertise with us

His sentencing is scheduled for Dec. 17, according to the release.

Waters and Costanzo owned multiple “second-hand” businesses in the region, named Trader Electronics, Last Call Entertainment and The Outlet, that were used as a cover to buy and resell stolen items, according to information presented to the court. Most of the items consisted of over-the-counter medications and beauty items, such as makeup and skincare products, as well as DVDs.

From 2013 to 2016, thefts occurred at different stores across the Pittsburgh region, according to the release. It was discovered by police that many of the items stolen from retailers were the same items being sold at Waters’ businesses, among other local resellers.

Records showed that Waters was purchasing thousands of stolen items from the same group of people and would then sell the items on different Amazon and Ebay accounts, according to the release. Those who would sell the stolen items to Waters’ businesses testified during trial that they only stole the items to get money to buy drugs.

Additionally, the sellers claimed that Waters had bailed them out of jail after being arrested for the thefts and he made them repay the bail cost through other stolen items, according to the release.

Advertise with us

An investigation into resellers like Waters and Costanzo turned up seven other businesses in the area, with Waters being the “eighth and final resale store owner to be found guilty,” the release said.

“Durrell Waters and his conspirators brazenly used their second-hand stores as a front for fencing massive amounts of shoplifted retail products — some with the store identification and security stickers still intact — that they then turned around and sold for millions of dollars to online customers across the United States,” said U.S. Attorney Eric G. Olshan in a statement. “To pull off their scheme, they relied on desperate people deep in the throes of addiction to maintain the flow of stolen goods, using them to steal from and ultimately undercut legitimate retailers.”