Nearly every seat in a Downtown Pittsburgh municipal courtroom was full Friday morning when several pro-Palestinian protesters faced preliminary hearings. 

Each time District Judge Daniel Butler called another person to the bench, supporters adorned in "Free Palestine" shirts and buttons grasped each other's hands. Some closed their eyes. Others winced, or exhaled sighs of relief. At times, some cried out in protest.

"This is so hard to watch," one woman whispered. 

Several University of Pittsburgh police officers also added to the tension in the courtroom as they testified about the incidents that took place on Pitt’s campus on June 3, which culminated when more than 30 protesters rushed a police barrier and dismantled it.

Advertise with us

During the hearing for Abiola Morakinyo, 23, Officer Benjamin Salvio alleged that she and two others pushed part of a police barrier on him, spraining his ankle and causing a host of other injuries. 

Officer Salvio also said he forgot to activate his body-worn camera that night, invoking audible gasps from observers. According to prosecutors, video footage shown from the incident was recovered from a different officer's body camera.

Shannon Haupt, Ms. Morakinyo's attorney, argued that her identity was unclear in the video footage and that Officer Salvio's injuries were not severe enough to warrant felony charges of aggravated assault and rioting. Her hearing was eventually rescheduled for Sept. 19.

Muhammad Ali, 21, was charged with aggravated assault, obstruction and disorderly conduct. Judge Butler moved his hearing to Aug. 26 because an officer who the prosecution expected to testify was on vacation.

In a heated exchange, Mr. Ali's attorney, Aaron Sontz, objected to the continuance and told prosecuting attorneys they "lost any moral high ground" because of the repeated rescheduling. 

Advertise with us

"We have a whole room of people who got here today, but for some reason, a [police officer] couldn't," he said. "Mr. Ali's family flew in from Abu Dhabi to be here today." 

Prosecutor James Sheets told Mr. Sontz the change was not unreasonable for someone facing multiple felony charges and warned that he could file a motion requesting that Mr. Ali’s bail be revoked, potentially sending him to jail. 

"That's not a threat; it's a promise," Mr. Sheets said amid cries of protests from observers. 

Three other protesters had their cases waived to court, and six also had their hearings rescheduled.

In early June, the area outside the Cathedral of Learning lawn spun into a tumultuous protest when demonstrators erected tents and fences as they demanded that Pitt disclose and divest any investments connected to Israel during the ongoing war in Gaza.

Advertise with us

But on the second night of demonstrations, interactions between protesters and police grew violent.  The conflict included a pink smoke bomb firework and water bottles thrown at police officers. 

Officers were seen throwing some protesters to the ground and paramedics and additional police units were called to the scene.