As Donald Trump’s would-be assassin crawled up the roof to take aim at the former president, local police were inside the same building the gunman used as a sniper’s nest on Saturday, the leader of the U.S. Secret Service said.
Despite police in and around the building, Thomas Matthew Crooks was able to scale an exterior wall, move into position, confront a local law enforcement officer with his rifle and fire a deadly salvo into a crowd of rally-goers.
The failure to secure the rooftop has become the focus of intense criticism of the protective agency and the local law enforcement they relied on to help guard the Republican nominee and his supporters at the Butler Farm Show.
The security breach took place after the Secret Service had increased protection around Trump ahead of the rally because of an Iranian plot to kill the former president that had been uncovered by intelligence agencies, the Associated Press reported. But the plot was unrelated to the assassination attempt in Butler County, security officials told the AP.
The ability of a 20-year-old to pierce that added security and position himself on an unguarded rooftop just 150 yards away from Trump has baffled security experts and fueled calls for investigations into the tragedy that left one dead and three wounded.
“There was local police in that building — there was local police in the area that were responsible for the outer perimeter of the building," Secret Service Director Kimberly Cheatle told ABC News on Monday.
Read More
People just outside the rally’s fenced-off area spotted the gunman as he climbed onto the building, filming him as he crawled forward and shouting and pointing to direct police to the threat. One officer tried to climb onto the roof but retreated after Crooks turned his gun on him, the Butler County sheriff has said.
Crooks opened fire moments after the confrontation.
“The big question is were officers supposed to be on the roof or were the officers supposed to be just observing the roof. I've been told the building was secured. What does that mean?” Donald Mihalek, a retired Secret Service agent and ABC News contributor, told the Post-Gazette.
The officers inside the building were reportedly members of Beaver County’s SWAT team. The Secret Service routinely relies on local agencies to provide the majority of officers needed to guard presidential campaign events that can draw thousands of supporters.
Planning and coordinating security for a single rally is a dayslong operation that brings together advance teams of Secret Services agents, counter-snipers, intelligence officers and local police commanders from departments across the nearby region.
Typically, the Secret Service will set up three rings of protection, said Mr. Mihalek, a 21-year veteran of the agency. The inner ring around the stage and seating area is the agency’s main focus. A secondary ring that the public can only access by going through metal detectors is usually staffed by Secret Service and police.
Beyond that, extending as far as 1,000 yards from the stage, is an outer ring patrolled by local police but still under the authority of the Secret Service — an area that, at the Butler County rally, included the industrial complex used by Crooks to fire into the crowd.
"It's a very involved process," said Antonio Sanchez, a former Miami-Dade command officer who has served on dignitary protection details with the Secret Service.
And elevated positions are always a priority, he said.
Experts say there are three main ways to secure them: locking down the building, erecting a barrier to block the sightline to the stage — or posting guards atop the building.
“I want to make sure that there's no ability to access that roof,” former Secret Service agent Jason Russell said.
Everyone — from the federal agent in charge to local cops — learns the security plan.
“Secret Service, before every protective movement, does a police briefing, and then the local law enforcement officers are with these Secret Service agents during walkthroughs, security plans, everything,” Mr. Mihalek said. “There are no secrets.”
If there’s a specific threat, intelligence agents warn police, snipers and the protective detail that is a candidate’s last line of protection, he said. It’s unclear how specific the threat against Trump was; Mr. Mihalek noted the regime has for years threatened retribution against Trump for ordering the killing of Qassem Soleimani, a top Iranian general, in early 2020.
If the intelligence is too sensitive to disclose to people without a security clearance, agents typically tell police commanders that a specific threat exists without disclosing highly sensitive information.
“That is shared with local folks. Whether it filters down to the rank and file is subjective,” Mr. Mihalek said. “I am almost 99.9% sure everybody was told there was a heightened threat level — because this entire election has a heightened threat level.”
As investigators probe the breakdowns that allowed Crooks to fire multiple rounds at Trump, officials including Butler County District Attorney Richard Goldinger have bristled at suggestions from the Secret Service that the rooftop was the responsibility of local law enforcement, rather than the federal agency that was coordinating security.
Police played a supporting role, but “the Secret Service was running the show,” Mr. Goldinger told the Post-Gazette earlier this week.
In the aftermath of the shooting, President Joe Biden and Congressional leaders have ordered three separate investigations into the Secret Service and the security failures at the Trump rally. On Friday, Ms. Cheatle is scheduled to testify in front of the House Government Oversight committee — a Republican-run panel that has launched aggressive probes of other top officials in the Biden administration.
During her ABC News interview Monday, Ms. Cheatle called the failures “unacceptable.”
“The buck stops with me,” she said.
Michael D. Sallah contributed. Mike Wereschagin: mwereschagin@post-gazette.com; @Wrschgn; Megan Guza: mguza@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.