A woman has been taken into custody by Pittsburgh Police after allegedly attacking an 18-year-old Wednesday on Smithfield Street, Downtown, which has seen a series of incidents that have drawn complaints about safety.

Shurontaya Festa, 27, has been charged with one count of aggravated assault and two counts of disorderly conduct. She is being held in the Allegheny County Jail, with a preliminary hearing set for June 13, according to court documents.

Officers were called to the 600 block of Smithfield around 5 p.m. Wednesday for reports of a fight. The victim told the police that she had been punched in the back of the head by an unknown woman, according to the criminal complaint.

As the victim tried to walk away, she told police, the woman kept punching and grabbed the victim by the hair, punching and kicking her in the face, according to the criminal complaint. Then the woman stopped attacking the victim and walked toward Liberty Avenue.

Advertise with us

From the description given by the victim, officers found Ms. Festa four blocks away. Ms. Festa told the police she was involved in a fight on Smithfield Street, saying that she felt the victim was “stalking her,” the complaint said. Pittsburgh Police then took Ms. Festa into custody.

The victim, Sofia Mancing, of Butler County, is an intern at Flying Scooter Productions Downtown. She started at her internship last week and has not been Downtown for “a long time before that,” she said Friday.

Ms. Mancing recounted the incident, saying that she was walking to the bus stop down Smithfield when she passed her alleged attacker. Ms. Festa started following her and she hit Ms. Mancing on the head with a shoe. Ms. Mancing tried to move away, but Ms. Festa grabbed her hair and threw her into the street, continuing to hit her, Ms. Mancing recalled.

Once Ms. Festa stopped hitting her, some bystanders helped her call the police and waited with her for them to arrive, she added. EMS then took her to the hospital following the incident, suffering from a concussion and broken nose.

With her internship requiring her to be Downtown, Ms. Mancing is nervous about returning to the area, she said. But she will be changing the way she gets there and back in light of what happened on Wednesday.

Advertise with us

“I don't want this to affect my ability to do a job that I'm passionate and excited about,” she said. “So I will be going back, but I definitely won't be taking the bus anymore. I don't want to have to walk down Smithfield or anywhere alone anymore. And I think I'll be able to carpool with another intern who lives near me.”

Police obtained security footage of the incident and said in the criminal complaint that if Ms. Mancing did not try to protect herself, she would have “sustained severe injuries.” Officers added in the complaint that it was clear that Ms. Festa’s intent was to significantly harm Ms. Mancing.

Wednesday’s attack is the latest incident on Smithfield Street that has caused concern among residents, businesses and officials.

Wiener World, a hot dog establishment that was on Smithfield Street for almost 60 years, put the building up for sale in August 2023 citing a rise of crime and violence. The Smithfield Street staple moved to the U.S. Steel Tower this week.

Owner Denny Scott told the Post-Gazette in April 2023 that he and his employees no longer felt safe at the location because of issues they confronted at their doorstep, such as drug overdoses and sex acts.

Advertise with us

“It’s not even hidden anymore. It’s not even in the shadows anymore. It’s right out in the open. It’s getting to be too much,” he said at that time.

Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey addressed the fears among residents and business owners in the fall, saying, “Downtown is doing well.”

“We still have a long way to go to turn Downtown around,” Mr. Gainey said at a press conference in September. “We’ll do whatever we need to do in order to change Downtown, but let’s not think that miracles happen overnight.”

Some incidents Downtown have continued, including an uptick in violence near Market Square confirmed by Pittsburgh Public Safety. Officials told the Post-Gazette that detectives were “monitoring the area” due to a recent uptick in fights last month.

But while Wednesday’s incident was “extremely unfortunate, isolated incidents like this can occur in any community,” said Lee Schmidt, director of Pittsburgh Public Safety, in a statement provided Friday.

Advertise with us

“The Department of Public Safety is aware of the incident that occurred this week and any events like this cause us concern,” he continued.

“Pittsburgh hosts tens of thousands of individuals attending major events during the summer months. Throughout it all, the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police, Pittsburgh Bureau of EMS, and Pittsburgh Bureau of Fire will continue to work hand-in-hand to keep all of Pittsburgh’s spectators safe and secure. I encourage everyone to look out for their neighbors, pay attention to what’s happening around them, and if they see anything concerning to say something.”

Ciara McEneany: cmceneany@post-gazette.com