In an emotional hearing Monday morning, friends and family of Tarae Washington told her killer just how much he took away from them.
“My baby girl was the glue to my family,” her mother, Donna Starling, told the courtroom. “My family lost such a precious being.”
Washington, 47, was found bloody and bound in her South Side Slopes home Jan. 5, 2023. She had been stabbed more than a half-dozen times, investigators said at the time, and her hands were cuffed behind her back.
The next day, a warrant was issued for her estranged husband, William Fitzgerald. Witnesses told police that Fitzgerald, 51, wanted to reconcile and Washington had no interest, although she was letting him stay in the home until he found somewhere else to live.
Police said he had sent photos of Washington’s body to a friend. He was arrested Jan. 9, 2023, on Interstate 79.
Ms. Starling said Washington’s grandchildren will only get to know their grandmother through memories now.
Read More
That’s all that remains for her, too, she said.
“All I have left are memories.”
In a letter read aloud in court by Tia Collins, Washington’s cousin, Sinurae Trippett lamented how she could not protect her best friend.
“Tarae protected me from two domestic violence situations,” Ms. Collins read from Ms. Trippett’s letter. “The fact that I couldn’t protect her from him will always bring tears.”
Washington was supposed to be a bridesmaid in Ms. Trippett’s wedding. After Washington was killed, she wrote, she canceled the wedding and eloped — she couldn’t bear to get married without Washington standing next to her.
Ms. Trippett wanted to be there in person, she said, but “I know I couldn’t maintain myself if I got in front of [Fitzgerald].
“We lost a great person because of him.”
Washington’s aunt, Deborah Starling, said her niece believed she had found a man of God in Fitzgerald.
“A life sentence is still ‘life.’ He will still wake up every morning and breathe God’s air into his lungs,” she said. “My prayer is that God will trouble his mind as he sits in that cell, day after day.”
She continued: “I pray that his mind is troubled with faces of his own loved ones in our beautiful Tarae’s face — suffering, handcuffed, going through agony. Then he will feel at least one-tenth of the pain that he placed upon this wonderful woman and this family.
“May God have mercy on his soul,” she said.
Fitzgerald, too, spoke in court.
“I’ve caused a lot of pain to family and friends of Tarae. I took the life of a beautiful person,” he said Monday. “I deserve to pay for it with the rest of my life.”
He turned to speak directly to Washington’s family, who had come to know him through his relationship with their daughter, their niece, their friend.
“There are so many levels of pain I’ve given you,” he said. “The only thing I can do is pray that God gives you new strength every day to cope.”
Washington’s mother leaned, sobbing, into the arms of a relative. Other family members wept openly as Fitzgerald spoke to them.
“I don’t get it — what happened to warrant this kind of response?” Common Pleas Judge Elliot Howsie asked Fitzgerald, referencing the murder. “It’s just tragic. You needlessly took her life.”
The judge’s sentencing was all but a formality, as Fitzgerald’s plea to first-degree murder meant a mandatory sentence of life in prison without the possibility of parole.
“I deserve it. I deserve more,” Fitzgerald told the judge.
“I do hope you spend the rest of your life thinking about the pain you caused,” Judge Howsie said. “Prayer is not enough.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.