If he hadn’t been slumped over in his gray baby bouncer, Jah’Shawn Martin might have looked like he was just sleeping.
The 5-day-old newborn was snug in a blue and white Cookie Monster onesie, and his eyes were closed. He was slumped at an unnatural angle, twisted slightly onto his left side with his head down near the seat of the bouncer. His right leg was on top of his left. His head was turned slightly, one hand in a tiny loose fist.
The photo, displayed on a screen in a near-empty courtroom Friday, was taken at 11:18 p.m. Dec. 15.
Though it’s not clear from the photo, prosecutors say that by that point, the baby had already sustained incredibly forceful crushing injuries to his head — the kind one forensic pathologist testified would come from being hit by a tractor trailer or from a fall of 20-30 stories.
The child’s father, 20-year-old Shawn Martin, is charged with homicide in the boy’s death, though his defense attorney maintained at his preliminary hearing that his client was sleeping on the couch in their Northview Heights apartment and has no idea what happened to his son.
District Judge Hilary Wheatley ultimately ruled there was enough evidence to hold Mr. Martin for trial. Formal arraignment is scheduled for March 25.
Read More
Jah’Shawn spent Dec. 15 with his father and his 2-year-old brother. He’d only come home from the hospital two days prior, and his mother was still hospitalized because of complications during his birth, police have said. Mr. Martin was the sole caretaker of his newborn at the time.
Mr. Martin told detectives the day went smoothly: He’d taken Jah’Shawn to his first check-up in Oakland about 3:45 p.m. and returned home with the baby and the toddler about 5 p.m. He did some work around the house, fed Jah’Shawn some Similac, burped him, and put him into his baby bouncer right next to the couch.
He fell asleep around 5:30 p.m. and awoke about 11 p.m. to find his neighbor waking him up, detectives testified. They said Mr. Martin told them he looked at the baby and he was fine. He got up, went to the bathroom and when he came back, the child was unresponsive on the couch.
“He said he was sleeping, had no idea what occurred,” Detective Daniel Soroczak testified.
The only non-law enforcement witness to testify at the hearing told a slightly different story.
Hezekiah Odom called Mr. Martin “a real close friend, like a cousin,” and said Mr. Martin had asked him to pick up a bottle of liquor for him while Mr. Odom was out and about. He got to the Fine Wine and Good Spirits on East Ohio Street on the North Side not long before their 9 p.m. closing and then caught the bus back to Northview Heights.
He spent about 15 minutes at Mr. Martin’s apartment but never saw the baby, Mr. Odom testified. He said he took two shots of the Jim Beam he’d bought, but he didn’t recall Mr. Martin taking any. He left when his girlfriend called him to come watch their kids.
Around 10:45 p.m., Jah’Shawn’s mother reached out to Mr. Odom via Facebook messenger. Mr. Odom said she was concerned because she’d been on the phone with Mr. Martin and heard the baby crying and, now, she couldn’t get ahold of him. Mr. Odom ultimately had to jimmy the backdoor of Mr. Martin’s apartment open to get inside and wake him up.
According to the initial criminal complaint against Mr. Martin, the child’s mother told police she’d been on the phone with Mr. Martin around 10 p.m. when they both drifted off still on the phone. When she awoke less than an hour later, she heard Jah’Shawn crying. She was unable wake Mr. Martin, investigators said, at which point she called a neighbor to go check on the father and son.
When Mr. Odom got inside, he took a photo of Jah’Shawn in his bouncer to send to the boy’s mother — he testified Friday that it was to show he was OK. He never heard the baby cry, he said, and he left shortly after he woke Mr. Martin up.
He took the photo at 11:18 p.m.
He’d only just walked back home and gone inside when Jah’Shawn’s mother called him back, he said. She told him the baby wasn’t breathing. He started to walk back to Mr. Martin’s apartment but took off in a full sprint when he saw the lights of the police and ambulance.
At Children’s Hospital, Mr. Martin told police he didn’t know what happened — he’d been asleep the whole time, detectives said he told them.
Jah’Shawn was pronounced dead shortly after 3 a.m. Dec. 16. He was just barely five days old.
Forensic pathologist Dr. Jennifer Hammers performed the autopsy on the infant. Her career has spanned more than 15 years and she’s performed some 5,000 autopsies. She testified that the blunt force trauma to Jah’Shawn’s head is the worst she’s seen in an infant.
There were fractures all around his skull, Dr. Hammer said, referring to the multiple fractures as coming from a crush-type blow. They went from the back around to the sides, and others extended to the front of his face.
He was bleeding below his scalp, she testified, and it had pooled in a spot that matched the way the infant was laying in his bouncer when Mr. Odom took the photo.
She said that in blunt force trauma cases, it was incredibly rare, in her experience, to see such extensive fractures. The amount of force needed to cause those injuries, she said, was extreme. Such severe injuries in an adult would come from a 20-30-story fall or from being struck by a tractor-trailer or bus.
It would take even more force to cause that kind of trauma to an infant’s head, she said, because their skulls are still pliable.
Dr. Hammers said there were severe injuries to the infant’s right arm as well.
Could that have been caused by someone picking him up by that arm and throwing or hitting him against the wall, Assistant District Attorney Emma Schoedel asked.
That could be a possibility, in her opinion, Dr. Hammers said.
What it couldn’t come from, she said, was an accident. A fall from 17 inches from the couch to the floor couldn’t cause that trauma, nor could a 5-inch fall from the baby bouncer. And a 2-year-old couldn’t generate enough force to cause those injuries either, she testified.
Mr. Martin was charged with homicide on Jan.12.
Detective James McGee said that when he interviewed Mr. Martin on Jan. 14, he and Detective Anthony Beatty went over every possibility: Could Mr. Martin have tripped while carrying Jah’Shawn? Were they in a car accident? Did Jah’Shawn fall from a window?
Detective McGee said Mr. Martin answered no — he said he had no idea what had happened but maintained that the only people in the apartment were himself, the 2-year-old, and Jah’Shawn.
The detective also said he’d listened to the recording of Mr. Martin’s 911 call. In the background, he said, Mr. Martin can be heard saying “I’m sorry.”
Throughout the 2-hour hearing, Mr. Martin became animated at times. He rocked back and forth from one foot to the other as he stood next to his attorney, Patrick Nightingale. Sometimes he wiped tears. He often shook his head in a vehement “no” motion as he listened to testimony.
In his brief arguments after witness testimony, Mr. Nightingale focused on the lack of any weapon inside the apartment that could have caused Jah’Shawn’s injuries.
“We simply don’t know what happened,” he said.
Ms. Schoedel said no weapon was necessary — a hard surface like a wall or a floor could have acted as a weapon if infant was thrown or struck against it.
“All you need is a baby, in this case infant Martin, and a hard surface,” she said, calling it inconceivable that Jah’Shawn could have suffered those injuries by anything other than his father’s hands.
“It’s impossible,” she said.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.