Moments before he was shot and killed in his Arlington apartment on Dec. 30, Grant Gibeault texted his neighbor that he “just got robbed at gunpoint.”
The neighbor responded with an explanation of disbelief: “WHAT,” followed seconds later by, “Please tell me that was your drums.”
Mr. Gibeault, 25, was pronounced dead a short time later by Pittsburgh paramedics. He’d been shot multiple times.
His neighbor would later tell police they heard five or six loud bangs just after Mr. Gibeault reported being robbed. When he didn’t respond to the text messages, the neighbor went and checked on him, ultimately finding his apartment door wide open and Mr. Gibeault dead on the ground with blood on his clothes.
On Monday, Pittsburgh police charged 20-year-old Jaelyn Nowlin, of Brighton Heights, with homicide in connection with the fatal shooting.
The criminal complaint against Nowlin indicates she saw Mr. Gibeault as “an easy target to rob,” and the shooting came after the CashApp transaction she demanded failed to go through.
Investigators used the CashApp receipts, text messages and fingerprints to link Nowlin to the killing.
According to the complaint, Mr. Gibeault exchanged text messages with someone going by the name Unique the day before the homicide. In those messages, “Unique,” later identified as Nowlin, asked for several hundred dollars up front before she would meet up with the victim at his apartment.
Nowlin allegedly told investigators several different stories during a Monday morning interview but ultimately explained that she’d sold Mr. Gibeault weed in the past and she’d been to his home several times. She said that during those times, according to the complaint, she spotted some things inside his apartment that she wanted to steal, specifically mentioning a PlayStation 4.
She told police she thought he would be an easy target and arranged a meet up under the fake name Unique on a dating app, according to the complaint. She said she disguised herself with makeup and a headscarf.
CashApp receipts from just before the neighbor reported hearing shots showed that Mr. Gibeault sent $700 to a user named “Business Woman” at about 8:06 p.m. Seconds later, his bank requested a confirmation via text message, according to the complaint. An email at 8:07 p.m. confirmed that “Business Woman just accepted the $700 you sent.”
After that, police said, the victim received a text message indicating the money had been refunded.
Nowlin first told police that she’d gone to Mr. Gibeault’s apartment and he “kept coming toward her” and “giving her a weird vibe,” according to the complaint. She alleged he sent her $700 in exchange for sex but left after he sent the money. She said she went back when she saw the transaction was canceled because she considered the cancelation an attempt to rob her.
She alleged that when she went back to his apartment, Mr. Gibeault lunged at her, and she ultimately shot him several times before “she blacked out,” according to the complaint.
In addition to homicide, Nowlin is charged with robbery and firearms violations. She remained held without bail in the Allegheny County Jail on Tuesday. Court records did not list an attorney. A preliminary hearing is scheduled for Jan. 19.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.