A lawsuit filed this week in the Court of Common Pleas accuses officers from McKeesport and the Allegheny County Police departments of unfairly targeting Black McKeesport residents with abusive and aggressive search tactics during the December 2020 manhunt for a man accused of shooting a McKeesport officer.

Koby Francis, 25, was taken into custody Dec. 20, 2020, after he allegedly violated a protection from abuse order. As McKeesport Officer Gerasimos Athans opened the rear door of his cruiser outside the police station, Francis shot at the officer with a weapon he’d managed to conceal during the preceding search. The officer was shot in the neck and shoulder. Francis escaped and Officer Athans survived his injuries.

Koby Francis (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Three McKeesport residents, all of whom are Black, are named as plaintiffs in the lawsuit, including Francis’s mother, Kim Neal. They say they were harassed by police and subjected to unconstitutional searches that were far more extreme than any searches targeting their white neighbors.

Francis was ultimately arrested Dec. 29, 2020, in West Virginia.

Advertise with us

During the nine days in between, the lawsuit alleges, Ms. Neal and two others, Courtney Thompkins and Ezra Dixon, suffered through traumatizing stops and searches by police looking for Francis.

The lawsuit, filed by the American Civil Liberties Union, names McKeesport and its police department, Allegheny County and the county police department, former McKeesport Chief Adam Alfer, Assistant Chief Mark Steele, and Officer Dante Diberadin. Former county police Superintendent Coleman McDonough is also named, as is former McKeesport officer Brenda Sawyer, who at the time was working with the state Attorney General’s Office.

According to the lawsuit, police came to Ms. Neal’s home she shared with her husband and 19-year-old son the same day as the shooting. She initially refused to let them inside without a warrant, but one law enforcement officer stepped inside and told her they didn’t need a warrant.

Ms. Neal said her family was placed under surveillance, and her daughter’s home was searched as well, forcing the woman’s two young children to wait outside “wearing nothing but diapers and underwear,” according to the lawsuit.

Another time, the lawsuit alleged, police would not allow Ms. Neal and her family back into their home because they said they saw movement inside. She refused to let them in without a warrant, and officers held them outside for hours, “all while continuing to threaten her and trying to coerce Ms. Neal into letting them in.”

Advertise with us

Similar situations continued to play out until Francis was taken into custody, according to the lawsuit.

In Ms. Thompkins case, attorneys said she noticed two police officers had stopped her partner outside their home as he left for work. When she went outside to see what was happening, according to the lawsuit, she was met with police in tactical gear with guns drawn.

Police demanded to search the house, the lawsuit alleged, and Ms. Thompkins eventually acquiesced “out of fear for her life” and the officers’ “coercive demands.” Officers did not offer a search warrant, she said, nor did they give any indication they had reason to believe Francis was in the house.

The lawsuit claims a white woman who lived a few houses away had an actual connection to Francis — someone who lived there was dating Francis’ brother — but “was not subjected to nearly the same level of police intrusion, intimidation or abuse as Ms. Thompkins and other Black residents of McKeesport.”

For Mr. Dixon, the lawsuit alleged, the stop by police came as he was driving home with a friend and acquaintance in the car with him. They were stopped at a roadblock and Mr. Dixon was forced out of the car and searched, according to the lawsuit.

The lawsuit alleges violations of the U.S. and Pennsylvania constitutions and claims of excessive force, racial discrimination, conspiracy and intentional infliction of emotional distress.