ATLANTA — The judge overseeing the criminal racketeering case against former president Donald Trump and 14 allies alleging they illegally conspired to overturn his 2020 election loss in Georgia issued a protective order barring public release of “sensitive” evidence in the matter.

In an order issued Thursday morning, Fulton County Superior Court Judge Scott McAfee said the recent release of recorded statements given to prosecutors by four Trump co-defendants who have accepted plea deals in the case warranted the imposition of the protective order. He said in addition to the possibility of exposing potential witnesses to threats or other dangers, the release of such pretrial materials to the public, including evidence that could eventually be deemed inadmissible, could taint potential jurors.

“The Court has an interest in ensuring that all parties retain their right to a fair trial before an unbiased jury, a process that could become unattainable should the public be allowed to vet every piece of unfiltered evidence months before trial,” Judge McAfee wrote.

Another reason for the order, the judge wrote, was to minimize the threat that future public release of materials could have a chilling effect on the parties’ willingness to share discovery material.

Advertise with us

“Only with full and unimpeded discovery will a case as cumbersome as this ever stay on track and be ready for trial without inordinate delay,” he said.

The order defines “sensitive materials” as “any evidence within the State’s discovery productions to the defendants and their counsel which the State believes in good faith is entitled to confidential treatment.”

Read More

The decision came after The Washington Post published details of the recorded statements of the four co-defendants. The recordings of interviews between prosecutors and pro-Trump attorneys Kenneth Chesebro, Jenna Ellis and Sidney Powell and Atlanta bail bondsman Scott Hall offered previously undisclosed details about the effort by Trump and his allies to reverse his defeat.

Following the video leak, the office of Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis filed an emergency request seeking a protective order — arguing the release was “clearly intended to intimidate witnesses in this case, subjecting them to harassment and threats before trial.”

Prosecutors had originally sought a protective order barring the public release of discovery material in September. But the order was still being negotiated between prosecutors and the litany of defense attorneys in the case, who have offered competing views on what should and should not be made public about the sprawling racketeering case.

Advertise with us

After the recordings were made public, Ms. Willis’ office said they would no longer share “confidential video recordings of proffers” to any defense attorneys involved in the case and would instead only allow counsel to view that material in person in their offices at the Fulton County Courthouse.

Prosecutors later backed off that idea, announcing in an emergency hearing on the issue Wednesday they had agreed to a proposed order put forward by an attorney for former Georgia Republican Party chair David Shafer and co-signed by several other defendants that would prohibit the release of evidence marked as “sensitive.”

Attorneys for three of Mr. Trump’s co-defendants — former Justice Department official Jeffrey Clark, Trump activist Harrison Floyd and Misty Hampton, the former elections director in Coffee County, Ga. —  indicated their clients opposed any limits on the sharing of discovery material.

“The information is largely already publicly available and has been released,” said Catherine Bernard, an attorney for Mr. Clark. “We do not believe a protective order is necessary.”

Jonathan Miller, an attorney for Ms. Hampton, admitted that he had provided recordings to the media. But he said Ms. Hampton opposed a protective order, citing her desire for the proceedings to be “100 percent transparent.” “This is ... one of the biggest cases the country has had. And that transparency is very important,” Mr. Miller said.

Advertise with us

Judge McAfee hinted Wednesday that there would be a protective order of some kind — though he also argued he was sensitive to concerns raised by an attorney representing The Post and other media organizations covering the case.

“Until we decide what’s going to be relevant and admissible, this case should be tried, and not in the court of public opinion as much as possible, but before a jury ... and with evidence that has been vetted and approved, “ Judge McAfee said during the Wednesday hearing.

The sweeping Fulton indictment, unsealed in August, accused Trump and 18 co-defendants of a wide-ranging conspiracy to steal the 2020 election.

The charges fall into several buckets of alleged criminal behavior: the meeting of the Trump slate of presidential electors in Atlanta; Mr. Trump’s pressure campaign seeking help from multiple Georgia state officials in reversing his defeat; a breach of election equipment in rural Coffee County, Ga., in a hunt for evidence of fraud; and harassment of two local election workers in Fulton County who were falsely accused of counting fraudulent ballots on election night. The case is separate from the federal election interference investigation by special counsel Jack Smith, in which only Mr. Trump has been charged so far.

The audible portions of the Fulton recordings reviewed by The Post do not appear to directly implicate Mr. Trump. But there was an indirect implication in Ellis’ proffer statement — that a top presidential aide had said to her in December 2020 that “the boss” did not plan to leave the White House “under any circumstances.”