Text messages and surveillance footage led Allegheny County police to the man they say shot and killed a local music producer earlier this year, according to charges filed Tuesday.

Isaiah Thornton, 34, is charged with homicide in connection with the May killing of 32-year-old Michael Tomlin.

Police responded to a home on Franklin Avenue in Wilkinsburg just before midnight May 27. The 911 caller said he was in his upstairs bedroom at the home when he heard a gunshot and saw Tomlin lying in the front entryway to the home, according to the complaint.

The witness, who said he was subletting a room to Tomlin, said they’d been drinking together for part of the night before Tomlin went upstairs to his bedroom, according to the complaint. The witness said he wasn’t sure what Tomlin was doing, but he knew Tomlin would sometimes sell marijuana.

Advertise with us

At the scene, police found two baggies of suspected marijuana, investigators said.

Cell phone records showed that in the time leading up to the shooting, Tomlin had been texting with someone who’d expressed interest in buying marijuana, investigators said. The texts took place over the course of the afternoon, with the other number at one point indicating he was at a nearby Jamaican restaurant.

About the same time Tomlin received that text, there was a car crash near the restaurant, police said. Security and police body camera footage from responding officers showed a bearded man with glasses wearing white shirt walking toward a Durango in the restaurant parking lot, according to the complaint. Investigators used the license plate of the Durango to trace it back to Thornton.

Thornton’s former parole officer identified the man in the video as Thornton, according to the complaint.

Other footage from cameras near the shooting scene showed the Durango driving toward Franklin Avenue shortly before the shooting, according to the complaint. It was around the same time that Tomlin was exchanging the text messages. The Durango stopped on Franklin Avenue for about three and a half minutes before taking off about 11:51 p.m., police said. The 911 call reporting the shooting came seconds after the SUV left.

Advertise with us

Previous text messages and surveillance footage indicated that Thornton had been to the Franklin Avenue home earlier that same day, according to the complaint.

The number Tomlin had been texting went back to a Trac phone, police said. They questioned the woman to whom it was registered said she’d bought it for a man she knew as “Wreck-It Ralph.” Shown a photo array, she identified a photo of Thornton as the man for whom she’d bought the phone.

Thornton was taken into custody Tuesday morning, police said.

Friends told Post-Gazette news partner KDKA-TV that Tomlin was a “true loving spirit, an energized spirit.”

Family and friends release red balloons Monday afternoon at the Point, Downtown, for Michael “Tomlinese” Tomlin, the victim of the Wilkinsburg shooting on Monday, May 30, 2023. (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“Anybody that came around him just loved him,” friend Jamal Campbell told the TV station in the days after Tomlin’s death.

Advertise with us

Tomlin worked as a producer and artist at WAMO 107.3

“He was a beautiful soul," Branon Ford told KDKA at a May 29 balloon release in Tomlin’s honor. "His music touched people, his laugh touched people. His sense of humor. His personality. You really couldn't be sad around Tomlin."