District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. wants to change the way in which preliminary hearings for homicide cases are traditionally held in Allegheny County, seeking to move such hearings from Pittsburgh Municipal Court to the Court of Common Pleas on Grant Street.

Mr. Zappala, a longtime Democrat running as a Republican to try to keep his post after a preliminary election loss earlier this year, specifically cited security, privacy, and technology concerns at the municipal court on First Avenue.

The motion was filed Aug. 9, according to the paperwork released by Mr. Zappala’s office. It was not immediately clear why it was only announced Wednesday.

The municipal courthouse, adjacent to the Allegheny County Jail, has long been the venue for charges filed in Pittsburgh or major crimes charged by Allegheny County Police. Preliminary hearings are often scheduled in groups, and some homicide hearings can last several hours.

Advertise with us

Hearings in municipal court are generally held in front of an Allegheny County magisterial district judge. The district magistrates cover municipal court cases on a rotating basis.

It was not immediately clear if Mr. Zappala’s plan would remove district magistrates from the picture when it comes to preliminary hearings in homicide cases.

The district attorney has been critical of at least one lower court judge recently, condemning a decision to release an alleged drug-trafficker on nonmonetary bail.

Yan Carlos Pichardo Cepeda, of New York, was arrested outside the Downtown Pittsburgh bus station Aug. 31 after officers noticed alleged suspicious behavior. Cepeda consented to a search, and authorities found nine kilograms of fentanyl in his backpack. That amount of the opioid painkiller — about 20 pounds — is worth about $1.6 million. It is enough for some 450,000 doses.

Magisterial District Judge Zander Orenstein ordered Cepeda to be released on nonmonetary bail. He did not show up for his next court hearing, and a nationwide warrant has been issued for the arrest.

Advertise with us

While the district attorney did not point to that specific incident — or any bail-related incident — in his motion, he alluded to it in a statement released by his office.

“In addition, recent events in the handling of serious and violent crime at city court require that more assets be more rapidly available to ensure that victims’ rights and the public safety remain critical considerations,” the statement read. “DA Zappala believes that the change of venue for these preliminary hearings will help avoid issues in the future.”

Mr. Zappala wrote in his motion to President Judge Kim Berkley Clark that the First Avenue facility “is not conducive to the unique safety measures required in the presentation of criminal homicide proceedings.”

He pointed to the singular entrance and metal detector in the municipal court building and overall lack of outside security. The Court of Common Pleas, however, has multiple entrances and exits with multiple metal detectors as well as security provided by sheriff’s deputies.

The possibility of violence or retaliation among family and friends of the victims and defendants also poses a risk, Mr. Zappala said, though he did not cite any recent examples of such issues. Witness intimidation and privacy for the family members were also among sticking points listed in Mr. Zappala’s motion.

Advertise with us

All of those potential pitfalls, he said, mean preliminary hearings for homicide cases should be moved to the Court of Common Pleas.

“[The] safety and security of all individuals attending and/or involved in preliminary hearings of criminal homicide prosecutions, the interest of justice demands the proper venue to ensure the safety and security of the public, witnesses, families, court officers, and the defendant is the Allegheny County Courthouse,” Mr. Zappala wrote in his motion.