Disgraced businessman Joseph Nocito Sr., whose lavish multi-million dollar Bell Acres home was built upon years of fraud, will spend one year in federal prison, a federal judge ruled Monday — not the mercy that Nocito and his family had pleaded for, but still a lesser prison term than federal prosecutors had called for.
“Mercy is not the overarching factor,” Senior U.S. District Judge Joy Flowers Conti said. “I have to impose a fair and just sentence.”
Nocito, 81, gripped a rosary as he awaited his sentencing.
He and his attorneys — as well as dozens of associates who filled the courtroom and flooded the judge with letters of support — had sought probation or house arrest for the $15 million tax fraud case
Nocito must report for his one-year-and-one-day prison sentence Jan. 22. It will be followed by three years of supervised release, the first six months of which will be under house arrest.
The house arrest, the judge said, cannot be served at Villa Noci, the 39,000-square-foot mansion that fraud built.
“I have embarrassed myself, my family, my friends, my employees, my fellow parishioners,” Nocito said in a brief statement before sentencing. “I did this myself.”
Nocito’s sentencing began last week when nine friends, family members and associates pleaded with Judge Conti for leniency in sentencing — chiefly, that he be given house arrest at one of his properties rather than the previously agreed upon three to four years in federal prison.
He suffers from cardiovascular issues, his attorneys said, he needs two knee replacements, and he had melanoma removed from his face last year.
“I beg of you to be as lenient as you possibly can in sentencing Joe,” his wife, Judith Nocito, asked Judge Conti last week. “Any incarceration is essentially a life sentence for both of us.”
Her husband reiterated that plea in his allocution Monday morning.
“I come before you embarrassed, ashamed, humbled, and respectfully ask this court for mercy,” he told the judge.
Central to the yearslong case — investigators began looking at Nocito’s finances in the mid-2000s — have been his accumulation of wealth, his complex network of business ventures and the sprawling Villa Noci. The 6.2-acre complex, according to property records, includes 12 bedrooms, 13 full bathrooms and 22 fireplaces.
The home and its contents — custom paintings and murals, custom floors, a gym, a wine cellar — were appraised at nearly $30 million, according to court records.
It was built and furnished upon fraud.
Nocito used his network of businesses to spend millions building the mansion, sometimes called “The Castle.” He used company money to pay for construction and the lavish interior, filing the ledger entries under headings such as “consulting” and “repairs and maintenance.” Among those “consulting” expenses, investigators said, were $76,000 worth of interior design kitchen work and $6,100 for wine cellar artwork.
Judge Conti seemed genuinely touched by the flood of support from friends, family members and associates. She said she’d never seen such an outpouring, nor had she ever seen so many people filling a courtroom for sentencing.
“You have done a lot of good,” she told Nocito. “No one can question that. No one can take away from you every good thing that has been said about you.”
Those factors, she said, all played into her sentencing decision. They also made the magnitude of the fraud “almost inexplicable” when viewed through the lens of the rest of Nocito’s life.
“Probation is not just punishment [in this case],” she told him. “I wish it were. I wish it was different. But I have to do my job.”
She encouraged those supporters to visit and write to Nocito in prison. She urged him to use the time — maybe around 10 months with good behavior, she noted — to get involved with the prison ministry and education programs.
“Think of all the good you could do,” she said. “You don’t have to waste your time.”
In November, Nocito pleaded guilty to one count of tax conspiracy in a plea agreement that called for 36 to 47 months in prison. Delays pushed that sentencing from its original date in March to Thursday. His restitution — nearly $16 million — has already been paid.
Nocito was indicted in early 2018 on one charge of conspiracy and nine counts of filing false tax returns, though the case against the former CEO of Automated Health Systems had been a long time coming.
The investigation came to light in 2015 when his then-secretary, Ann Harris, pleaded guilty to conspiring with her then-boss to shield some $27 million from the IRS. Harris, in pleading guilty, agreed to cooperate in the case against Nocito.
Nocito on Monday apologized for “putting [Harris] in jeopardy for my own gain.” His attorney said she continues to work for him.
The fact that Nocito, then a certified public accountant, drew others into his scheme, Judge Conti said, was among other factors considered in sentencing.
“You had the knowledge, you had the training, you had the experience,” she said. “You knew exactly what you were doing.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.