The 15-year saga of Joseph Nocito Sr. and his Villa Noci — a Bell Acres millionaire and his sprawling mansion funded by years of fraud — will continue a little longer after a federal judge on Thursday ended sentencing proceedings just before the disgraced businessman was set to deliver his own remarks.
U.S. District Judge Joy Flowers Conti said she hadn’t anticipated the 1:30 p.m. sentencing hearing would take so long. The hearing started about 10 minutes late and recessed for about 15 minutes at 4:30 p.m. for the judge to take a pressing phone call.
The proceedings will resume 9 a.m. Monday.
Sentencing for the 81-year-old Nocito has been more than a decade in the making. The investigation into the finances of his numerous companies began in the mid-2000s, and he was indicted for tax fraud in 2018.
Central to the years-long case are Nocito’s wealth, his complex network of business ventures, and his 6.2-acre property dubbed Villa Noci — a sprawling 39,000-square-foot mansion that, according to property records, includes 12 bedrooms, 13 full bathrooms, and 22 fireplaces.
The home and its contents — custom paintings and murals, custom floors, a gym, a wine cellar — were appraised at nearly $30 million, according to court records.
It was built and furnished upon fraud.
Nocito used his network of businesses to spend millions building the mansion, sometimes called “The Castle.” He used company money to pay for construction and the lavish interior, filing the ledger entries under headings such as “consulting” and “repairs and maintenance.” Among those “consulting” expenses, investigators said, were $76,000 worth of interior design kitchen work and $6,100 for wine cellar artwork.
In November, Nocito pleaded guilty to one count of tax conspiracy in a plea agreement that called for 36 to 47 months in prison. Delays pushed that sentencing from its original date in March to Thursday. His restitution — nearly $16 million — has already been paid.
Nocito and his attorney, Phil DiLucente, had appealed to Judge Conti for a more lenient sentence than the one agreed upon — chiefly, house arrest at a property other than the palatial Villa Noci — citing his age and health. He needs two knee replacements, defense counsel wrote in a mid-August filing, and struggles with his gait. Stairs give him trouble, attorneys wrote, and he had surgery to remove melanoma in 2022 — a condition that must be monitored for a recurrence, according to the filing.
On top of that, attorneys wrote, Nocito has “significant cardiovascular problems” and needs a “variety of medications.”
“Simply put,” the filing read, “Mr. Nocito is not a person who can acclimate to prison.”
Prosecutors in the case scoffed at that notion in their Aug. 24 response to the motion.
“He is not non-ambulatory, wheelchair-bound, or bedridden. He is certainly not an invalid,” prosecutors wrote. “Indeed, of the listed medications [Nocito takes], many are routine ‘over-the-counter’ vitamins or health supplements not designed to treat any disease.”
On Thursday, nine character witnesses spoke on behalf of Nocito, championing his kindness and generosity and asking Judge Conti to have mercy on the man many said was like a brother to them.
“Joe is not the totality of this transgression,” the Rev. Nicholas Vaskov told the judge.
Indeed, that was the refrain of many witnesses who testified on Nocito’s behalf, including his attorney, Mr. DiLucente.
“Joseph Nocito is the most unselfish man I’ve ever met in my life,” the attorney said during a lengthy monologue attesting to his client’s character and the health declines he’s seen in the years he’s represented Nocito.
He said Nocito can no longer take the stairs to his law office — something he could do years ago. Mr. DiLucente also said he fears for his client’s safety if he were to be sentenced to prison.
“He isn’t that tough, strong man that walked into my office,” Mr. DiLucente said. “He’s not a weak man, but he is weakening, and I believe he will continue to.”
Nocito’s wife, Judith Nocito, was among those to testify to both her husband’s character and his declining health.
She said Villa Noci was not built for any reason other than “to welcome family and friends” and create a warm and welcoming place. She spoke of the family’s weekly Sunday dinner tradition that holds without fail, and she said her husband was speaking of such gatherings before construction had even begun.
Ms. Nocito spoke of her husband’s decreased mobility and the stumbles she’s witnessed. She said any period of incarceration would cause her fear for his physical health, his safety, and his morale.
“I beg of you to be as lenient as you possibly can in sentencing Joe,” she told Judge Conti. “Any incarceration is essentially a life sentence for both of us.”
Federal prosecutor Gregory Melucci likened Nocito’s life and legacy to a Shakespearean tragedy — one brought on by unbridled ambition.
“His singular focus was to acquire and hoard as much as he could … and hide it from the IRS in any way he could,” Mr. Melucci said.
It was hidden, he said, in the form of Villa Noci. He said the United States helped him earn “wealth beyond his wildest imagination” and, in return, “he gave them lies.”
That’s where the tragedy concludes, he said: “The vision of Mr. Nocito becomes his demise.”
The case itself has been as sprawling as Villa Noci.
Nocito was indicted in early 2018 on one charge of conspiracy and nine counts of filing false tax returns, though the case against the former CEO of Automated Health Systems had been a long time coming.
The investigation came to light in 2015 when his then-secretary, Ann Harris, pleaded guilty to conspiring with her then-boss to shield some $27 million from the IRS. Harris, in pleading guilty, agreed to cooperate in the case against Nocito.
The investigation into Nocito’s finances began nearly a decade before his indictment. The scheme centered around his massive estate, which some estimates peg as worth $20 million, and how exactly it was built and paid for.
Investigators said they believed that Nocito and others used his wide network of companies to hide income and paint the home’s construction as business expenses. Among his firms at the time were Automated Health Systems, Nocito Enterprises, Automated Health Services, Management Financial Services, Northland Properties, Palace Development Co., Donotti Properties and Jonolley Properties.
Investigators founds dozens of company ledger entries that painted building and other personal expenses as legitimate costs faced by his companies. Ledger entries were written as categories such as “consulting,” or “repairs and maintenance,” and construction invoices were paid through Nocito’s companies.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.