One by one, they filed to the front of the fifth-floor courtroom — a place where most have spent each day for more than two months.
They spoke of times before Oct. 27, 2018, when a gunman tore through the Squirrel Hill synagogue where congregations Tree of Life, Dor Hadash and New Light worshipped.
They spoke of the times after that. The finding out, the pain, the grief, the trial of Robert Bowers, and his sentence of death returned a day prior by the jury.
They spoke of their lost loved ones: Joyce Fienberg, Richard Gottfried, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Dan Stein, Melvin Wax, and Irving Younger.
They spoke to a courtroom packed with their friends and fellow congregants ahead of U.S. District Judge Robert J. Colville’s formal sentencing of the shooter to die by execution.
The atmosphere Thursday was different though. The defendant, no longer with a jury to sit in judgment of him, wore the standard-issue red jumpsuit from the Butler County Prison where he has been housed. He donned a rotation of dark-colored sweaters and collared shirts through the duration of jury selection and trial. The U.S. marshals who hovered near him wore khakis and windbreakers instead of suits.
Read More
They spoke to the defense attorneys.
For Michael Hirt, brother-in-law to the Rosenthal brothers, it was to lambaste the defense attorneys for their humanity toward their client.
For survivor Dan Leger, it was to thank them for valuing the sanctity of life “even though their client didn’t.”
They spoke to the judge, who presided over the case from early 2022 through its conclusion this week.
Diane Rosenthal thanked Judge Colville, a Pittsburgh native, for his “respectful insistence on courtroom decorum” and the sensitively light-hearted moments he brought to proceedings at times.
They spoke to the prosecutors — to U.S. Attorney Eric Olshan and Assistant U.S. Attorneys Soo C. Song, Troy Rivetti, and Nicole Vasquez Schmitt. Many thanked them by name for the care they gave to a horrific case.
They spoke to the shooter.
“Mr. Bowers, you met my beloved husband in the kitchen,” began Peg Durachko, Richard Gottfried’s wife. “He was not an evil man. He loved God. Rich was also a generous man. If you were hungry, he would’ve given you something to eat.
“What did you do instead?” she continued. “You riddled his body with bullets. For what? So that you could feel powerful, dominant, in charge?”
The man to whom she spoke never looked up.
“Your hateful act took my soulmate away from me, left me totally alone,” she said.
She asked the shooter if he ever wondered why he didn’t die that day.
God kept you alive, she told him. Now repent, she said.
“He is the just judge who determines where you will spend eternity,” Ms. Durachko said. “You will not have a team of lawyers to help you.”
Jerry Younger, son of Irving Younger, also spoke directly to the shooter.
But first, he prayed aloud. Then he spoke to the man who killed his father.
“Robert Bowers, I completely forgive you,” Mr. Younger said. “You are completely forgiven by me.”
The shooter did not look up.
Mr. Younger spoke of his Christianity and Jesus’ love. He said as long as the defendant has air in his lungs, he has a chance to repent.
“I love everyone in this courtroom,” he said, naming off the prosecutors and then turning to the defense. “I love them all, and that man, Robert Bowers, is no exception.”
Pittsburgh police Officer Michael Smigda tried not to speak to the shooter. He tried to contain his rage.
“I wrote so much, and I don’t know what to say,” he said. “It just doesn’t make sense. The things I’ve thought about wanting to do to him — one man shouldn’t have that kind of rage for another.”
His rage toward the shooter threatened to boil over during his brief statement.
“I just can’t express my sorrow for his victims and families,” Officer Smigda said. “Their impact statements have more impact on me than they ever will on him.”
Allan Mallinger, too, addressed the man who killed his mother, Rose, and wounded his sister, Andrea Wedner.
“I won’t sit here and list all the horrific things you’ve done to me and my family because you would enjoy that,” he said.
Instead, Mr. Mallinger told him, he would focus on the future.
“The synagogue will be rebuilt, the joy you took away will be reclaimed. My children will have their wedding there. Their children will have their bar and bat mitzvahs there,” he said. “We have suffered and fought for thousands of years before you came along and we will continue after you’re gone. Enjoy the show from prison while you can.”
Marc Simon keeps the prayer shawl that his father, Sylvan Simon, wore the day of the shooting. It’s the same prayer shawl that his mother, Bernice Simon, used in an attempt to stop her husband’s bleeding.
Mr. Simon also keeps the bloody string of pearls his mother wore that day. She’d worn the same pearls 62 years earlier when she married her husband in the same chapel where they died.
“They haunt me now and always will,” he said. “But I can’t part with them.”
He spoke directly to the man who killed his parents.
“There is no manliness, no machismo in murdering. Only cowardice, weakness and spinelessness,” Mr. Simon said. “You single-handedly also destroyed your own life and your own self in totality.”
“I waited four-plus years to get justice for them, and that finally happened yesterday,” said his sister, Michele Weiss. “Now I can finally learn how to live my life without my parents.”
“You cannot imagine the terror I felt that day,” Ms. Wedner said. “In the blink of an eye, my life changed. My mother was killed. After we were shot, I waited 40 agonizing minutes until we were found, not knowing if I would bleed out.”
Her voice started out shaky when she began her statement. That shake was gone by the end.
“The repugnant beliefs of this man have irrevocably altered not only my life, but my family’s,” Ms. Wedner said. But terror won’t win, she said. She refuses to “let the shooting destroy my life.”
Not once did the shooter look at anyone who spoke — not at the people he shot and didn’t kill and not at the reeling loved ones of those he did.
“Look at me — the Jew he tried to kill. I am not a ‘dirty [antisemitic slur],’” Mr. Leger said, referring to hundreds of abhorrent antisemitic social media posts the shooter made in the months before the shooting.
“I am a Jew,” he said.
And some just spoke out loud, to no one in particular, putting their pain and grief and four years’ worth of waiting into words and into the universe.
They spoke of the unique pain they’ve faced, the void left behind that only their loved one could fill.
Sharyn Stein, Dan Stein’s wife, talked about the lack of opportunity the couple had to fulfill their dreams.
The family of Cecil and David Rosenthal said in a joint statement that every year on Oct. 27, they will make a donation in the shooter’s name to an immigration services organization. They will mail him a receipt of the donation.
Rabbi Doris Dyen and her husband, Deane Root, spoke about the cognitive effects the shooting had on them. They came to door of the synagogue that morning and heard gunfire. Both struggle with concentration and focus, and both startle at any sudden sound.
Congregant Stephen Weiss now attends services armed.
Debi Salvin celebrates each birthday now without her twin brother, Richard Gottfried.
There are some things Pittsburgh SWAT Officer Jonathan Craig can remember about Oct. 27, 2018.
He remembers how little traffic there was. He remembers running toward the synagogue after he parked on Solway Street — “it seemed like it was never-ending.”
Other things he does not remember.
He doesn’t remember seeing SWAT Officer Timothy Matson, his best friend of more than a decade, walk into the room where they shooter lay in wait. He doesn’t remember hearing the first volley of gunfire.
But he does remember trying to get close — close enough “to do something, anything,” he said. And he remembers Officer Matson falling at his feet, saying, “I’m [expletive] up.” Later, he said, Officer Matson said he’d have only ever said that to him.
The two were as close as brothers, Sgt. Craig said. It made sense that Officer Matson would know he was at his friend’s feet without looking up.
He remembers hearing his friend screaming in pain. He remembers the shooter eventually calling out that he’d been shot and he needed help.
“How cowardly,” Sgt. Craig said. “He wanted help and mercy even though he gave none to the victims.”
As the shooter crawled out, Sgt. Craig kept his gun trained on him. He said he’d hoped the shooter would make some sort of threatening move, “so I could end his life right then and there.
“It took every ounce of strength not to stoop to his level and do it anyway,” he said.
Eventually, when the shooter was in custody and the threat was over, he remembers finding a chair. He remembers that he sat down and cried. He doesn’t remember for how long.
Tree of Life Rabbi Jeffrey Myers said that even now, some nights he is listless. At times he is inconsolable. Sometimes he cannot focus or concentrate on anything at all. He said he’s come to see that this journey will be filled with “storms and common wonders.”
The rabbi said he couldn’t drive past his synagogue for more than a year. One day, he did. He got stuck at the red light at Shady and Wilkins avenues.
“This looks like a mausoleum,” he said he thought to himself. “The Tree of Life died that day. My beloved synagogue … was the 12th victim.”
Congregations need a minyan to hold certain parts of services. A minyan is 10 or more Jewish adults. Rabbi Myers lost 70% of his minyan in the shooting. He said he doesn’t know if his congregation can make a minyan on its own again.
“This day may be one of the final nails in the coffin of Tree of Life,” he said. “It’s one thing to rebuild a damaged building. It is another to rebuild a faith community.”
Marty Gaynor said his dear friend Jerry Rabinowitz still visits him in his dreams sometimes. It is nice to see him, he said, but the dreams leave him sad and empty.
“He should still be here,” Mr. Gaynor said.
So should Carol Black’s brother, Richard Gottfried, she said.
“I live without my little brother who was more than a brother — he was my friend,” she said.
She said she heard gunfire in her head for months, and she cannot forget Melvin Wax being shot to death in front of her as she hid in a darkened closet.
She said their names, weeping harder with each one.
“Joyce Fienberg. Rose Mallinger. Jerry Rabinowitz. Cecil Rosenthal. David Rosenthal. Bernice Simon. Sylvan Simon. Dan Stein. Melvin Wax. Irving Younger. And,” she sobbed, “my beloved brother Richard Gottfried.”
They spoke for their lost loved ones, themselves, for the lives they had before Oct. 27, 2018.
They said all that could be said, Judge Colville told them. He said there was nothing more he could add that would say more.
For the first time during the proceedings, the shooter looked up, watching Judge Colville instead of furiously writing.
“Frankly I have nothing specific that I care to say directly to Mr. Bowers,” the judge said. “I mean no particular offense. I am convinced that there is nothing I could say to him that might be meaningful.”
He praised the attorneys on both sides. He praised the jurors, who were discharged Wednesday and sent home to try to get back to their lives. He praised the families and victims and survivors.
He said those who bore witness to their pain in the courtroom will never forget what was said.
“Indeed,” he said, “may their memories be a blessing.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.