Jurors in the case against Pittsburgh synagogue shooter Robert Bowers will begin deliberating his sentence this week, two months after the trial opened in late May.
There are only two options for Bowers’ sentence: life in prison with no possibility of release or a death sentence. A sentence of death must be unanimous among the 12 deliberating jurors.

Prosecutors in the case have argued to jurors that the heinousness of the Oct. 27, 2018, mass shooting means the defendant should receive the ultimate punishment. Bowers’ defense team has presented evidence of mental illness and a childhood marred by trauma.
Among evidence presented last week by defense attorneys: the harsh conditions at ADX Florence in Colorado, the most secure federal supermax prison reserved for prisoners who need the highest level of security.
If Bowers’ sentence is life, he will likely spend his remaining days at the 37-acre complex in the foothills of the Rockies. He will have a concrete bed against a concrete wall, and he will likely be confined to his concrete cell for 20-23 hours every day, two former federal Bureau of Prison employees testified last week.
Maureen Baird, a former federal prison warden who retired in 2016 after a nearly 30-year career, said that given Bowers’ notoriety and the hate-based nature of his crimes, she’s of the opinion he would be held at ADX.
Now a consultant with a firm called Prisonology, Ms. Baird said because Bowers’ victims were largely elderly or otherwise vulnerable, Bowers himself could be a target for other inmates at a facility that doesn’t have the highest restrictions. Bowers’ notoriety and potential as a target would endanger not just him, but the facility as a whole should there be some sort of assault.
“The only place he could safely go is ADX, given the circumstances,” she told jurors last week, though she acknowledged there are “no absolutes.”
Bowers killed 11 when he attacked the synagogue that housed the congregations Tree of Life, Dor Hadash and New Light. They were: Joyce Fienberg, Richard Gottfried, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax, Irving Younger.
Jurors in June convicted Bowers on all 63 federal charges against him.
Ms. Baird painted a picture for jurors of a harsh, stark facility in which Bowers would have little if any contact with other inmates. Even his recreation time would be alone and enclosed.
“It would be in a cage,” she said.
But, Ms. Baird said on cross-examination by Assistant U.S. Attorney Nicole Vasquez Schmitt, good behavior could potentially earn Bowers more privileges, including more recreation time and more phone calls.
A step-down program could mean Bowers could earn the privilege to participate in trivia and bingo games and have approved arts and crafts materials.
There are plans in place for ADX inmates to get electronic tablets, and they could potentially have a betta fish, also known as a Siamese fighting fish.
Ms. Baird said it’s safer for staff when inmates have something to occupy their time.
There are 327 inmates at ADX, some of whom are held in the facility’s H-unit, the most secure and restricted unit in the prison. Inmates held in that unit are labeled with what are called special administrative measures, or SAMs. SAMs designations are initiated by the Department of Justice, not the Bureau of Prisons.
There is no end date for SAMs, though inmates can appeal the designation. Through good conduct, they can be moved to the general population, though Ms. Baird noted that “general population” at ADX is not the same as a standard, non-supermax facility.
Ms. Vasquez Schmitt pressed Ms. Baird on the fact that there was no guarantee Bowers would end up in the facility’s most secure area or in ADX at all.
Only about 10% of the inmates at ADX were sent there directly after sentencing. Most are transferred from other facilities because of violent behavior while incarcerated, Ms. Vasquez Schmitt said. It’s generally not a facility intended for permanent placement.
The prosecutor cited numbers from the Bureau of Prison’s central inmate monitoring system, which tracks designations like those related to notoriety. She said of the 228 inmates with that classification, 18 are housed at ADX.
While it’s not clear who those 18 inmates are, there are some well-known names housed among the Florence facility’s population. Among them: Eric Rudolph, who killed three in four bombings carried out over two years in the mid-1990s, including the Centennial Olympic Park bombing.
Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, the surviving Boston Marathon Bomber, is also housed there. Terry Nichols, a co-conspirator in the Oklahoma City bombing, is serving his 161 life sentences in the ADX. Unabomber Ted Kaczynski was housed there until his death earlier this year. His 16 mail bombs over a 20-year span killed three people.
Rudolph, Tsarnaev, and Kaczynski were each represented by Bowers’ lead defense attorney, San Diego-based Judy Clarke.
Janet Purdue, another former BOP warden who is also now a consultant at Prisonology, agreed with Ms. Baird’s assessment of Bowers.
“The notoriety of him and his crime would complicate his security,” she said. “I would believe he would be a difficult inmate to keep safe.”
His potential as a target is also a risk to the good order of the facility. Any time there is an assault and corrections officers have to respond, there’s a risk involved.
“People can get hurt in these situations,” Ms. Purdue said.
She and Ms. Baird both toured the ADX and met with the facility’s attorney, Chris Synsvoll. Ms. Purdue said in her discussions with Mr. Synsvoll, he spoke as though it was a certainty that Bowers would be housed there if sentenced to life in prison.
“He made it fairly plain to us that Mr. Bowers would be housed at ADX,” she said. “We spoke as if he would be coming there.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.